62025TN0886
· Procedural documentAction brought on 23 December 2025 – De Masi v Commission
(Case T-886/25)
(C/2026/1075)
Language of the case: German
Parties
Applicant: Fabio De Masi (Berlin, Germany) (represented by C. Degenhart, university teacher)
Defendant: European Commission
Form of order sought
The applicant claims that the Court should:
—
annul Decision E-001110/2025 (1) of the European Commission of 27 October 2025;
—
order the Commission to pay the costs.
Pleas in law and main arguments
In support of the action, the applicant relies on the following pleas in law.
1.
Breach of the Commission’s duty to reply under the second paragraph of Article 230 TFEU due to an incomplete reply to a question
—
On 14 March 2025, the applicant, as a Member of the European Parliament, put a question for reply in writing to the European Commission, pursuant to the second paragraph of Article 230 TFEU, by which he requested information concerning any contacts between the President of the Commission and representatives of the arms industry. Despite requesting updates on numerous occasions, he received the Commission’s reply only on 27 October 2025. According to the applicant, his request of 14 March 2025 was answered in that reply only in part. The reply mentions only a few meetings and refers to the Transparency Register, press releases and social media in a general manner, while leaving the questions in relation to phone calls and text messages unanswered. The applicant argues that the Commission therefore, for the most part, refused to reply and thus is in breach of the applicant’s rights as a Member of Parliament arising from the second paragraph of Article 230 TFEU.
2.
Breach of the Commission’s duty to answer the question for written reply in good time, in accordance with the second paragraph of Article 230 TFEU.
—
The Commission’s statement that the question was phrased in a broad manner cannot justify the duration of more than seven months which it took the Commission to deal with the request. Therefore, the applicant submits that the Commission is in breach of its duty to reply by unlawfully failing to answer the applicant’s request made under the second paragraph of Article 230 TFEU within a reasonable time.
(1) The decision is a letter of the Commission President on behalf of the Commission as answer to the following parliamentary question by the applicant: E-10-2025-004415_EN.pdf.