Details
ECLI
Source
Decision form
Issue date
Last update
File mark
Court
Jurisdiction
Judge
Žiadne známe citácie.
62025CJ0241_en.html
HTML · 53.79 KB
No categories available
62025CJ0241
Provisional text
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT (Grand Chamber)
17 November 2026 (*)
In Case C‑241/25,
REQUEST for a preliminary ruling under Article 267 TFEU from the Högsta förvaltningsdomstolen (Supreme Administrative Court, Sweden), made by decision of 25 March 2025, received at the Court on 28 March 2025, in the proceedings
Société Générale SA
v
Skatteverket,
THE COURT (Grand Chamber),
composed of K. Lenaerts, President, T. von Danwitz, Vice-President, F. Biltgen, K. Jürimäe, M.L. Arastey Sahún, Z. Csehi and B. Smulders, Presidents of Chambers, S. Rodin, E. Regan, A. Kumin (Rapporteur), D. Gratsias, M. Gavalec, O. Spineanu-Matei, M. Bošnjak and A. Kornezov, Judges,
Advocate General: J. Richard de la Tour,
Registrar: C. Strömholm, Administrator,
having regard to the written procedure and further to the hearing on 10 February 2026,
after considering the observations submitted on behalf of:
– Société Générale SA, by L. Back, advokat, and O. Salenstedt, biträdande jurist,
– Skatteverket, by K. Hjelmberg and U. Vretendahl, acting as Agents,
– the Swedish Government, by H. Eklinder and R. Shahsavan Eriksson, acting as Agents,
– the German Government, by J. Möller and R. Kanitz, acting as Agents,
– the Spanish Government, by P. Pérez Zapico and A. Pérez-Zurita Gutiérrez, acting as Agents,
– the European Commission, by P. Carlin and W. Roels, acting as Agents,
after hearing the Opinion of the Advocate General at the sitting on 18 June 2026,
gives the following
Judgment
1 This request for a preliminary ruling concerns the interpretation of Article 63 TFEU.
2 The request has been made in proceedings between Société Générale SA, a company incorporated under French law, and the Skatteverket (Swedish Tax Authority, Sweden) concerning the latter’s refusal to refund withholding tax levied on dividends received by that company in 2012.
Legal context
European Union law
3 Article 63(1) TFEU provides:
‘Within the framework of the provisions set out in this Chapter, all restrictions on the movement of capital between Member States and between Member States and third countries shall be prohibited.’
4 Under Article 65 TFEU:
‘1. The provisions of Article 63 shall be without prejudice to the right of Member States:
(a) to apply the relevant provisions of their tax law which distinguish between taxpayers who are not in the same situation with regard to their place of residence or with regard to the place where their capital is invested;
…
3. The measures and procedures referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2 shall not constitute a means of arbitrary discrimination or a disguised restriction on the free movement of capital and payments as defined in Article 63.
…’
The Franco-Swedish Agreement
5 Article 10 of the Agreement between the Government of the French Republic and the Government of the Kingdom of Sweden for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention of Tax Evasion in respect of Taxes on Income and Wealth, signed in Stockholm on 27 November 1990, provides:
‘1. Dividends from a company resident in one contracting State to a person resident in the other contracting State are taxable in the latter State.
2. Those dividends may also be taxed in the contracting State in which the company paying the dividends is resident, under the legislation of that State, but if the recipient of the dividends is the person actually entitled to them, the tax thus levied may not exceed 15[%] of the gross amount of the dividends. …
…’
Swedish law
Provisions governing the tax on dividends
6 The provisions governing the tax on dividends are contained in the Kupongskattelagen (1970:624) (Law (1970:624) on the Tax on Dividends; ‘the Law on the Tax on Dividends’).
7 According to the first subparagraph of Paragraph 1 of that law, the tax on dividends must be paid to the State for any distribution of dividends on shares in a Swedish limited company.
8 The first subparagraph of Paragraph 4 of that law provides that non-resident legal persons who are entitled to dividends are liable for the tax if the dividends paid are not attributable to revenue from an economic or commercial activity carried out through a permanent establishment operating in Sweden.
9 Paragraph 5 of the Law on the Tax on Dividends provides that the rate of tax on dividends is to be 30% of the dividends distributed.
10 Paragraph 27 of that law provides that there is a right to refund in some situations. In accordance with the first subparagraph of Paragraph 27 of that law, if the tax on dividends has been levied at a higher rate than that laid down by an agreement for the avoidance of double taxation, the recipient is entitled to a refund of the excess amount levied.
11 Paragraphs 28 to 28n of the Law on the Tax on Dividends, which entered into force on 1 January 2020, provide for a deferral of the payment of the tax on dividends in certain cases, allowing a non-resident legal person established in the European Union to obtain, on request, a deferment in the payment of the tax on dividends. In essence, a deferral is to be granted provided that the non-resident legal person records a loss, calculated in accordance with the rules of Swedish tax law. If the legal person applying for a deferral forms part of a group of undertakings which is subject to the consolidated taxation of revenue in the State in which it is established, the extent of the deferral is to be calculated by reference to all of the undertakings in the group.
Provisions governing income tax
12 Chapter 6 of the Inkomstskattelagen (1999:1229) (Law (1999:1229) on Income Tax; ‘the Law on Income Tax’) includes Paragraphs 3 and 4, which provide that, as a general rule, Swedish legal persons are subject to income tax on all their revenue gained in Sweden and abroad.
13 Under the first subparagraph of Paragraph 1 of Chapter 16 of that law, Swedish legal persons may in principle deduct, as a cost, expenditure incurred in order to acquire and retain revenue.
14 The Law on Income Tax has no rules on consolidated taxation for undertakings which are part of a group. They may, however, if certain requirements are met, balance their results within the group by making intra-group transfers, pursuant to Chapter 35 of that law. It is apparent from the first subparagraph of Paragraph 1 of that chapter that such a transfer is deductible by the undertaking which carries it out and that it is taxable for the undertaking which receives it.
The dispute in the main proceedings and the questions referred for a preliminary ruling
15 Société Générale is a company established in France and belongs to a group of companies which is subject to consolidated taxation in that Member State.
16 In 2012, it received dividends from Swedish companies on which Swedish dividend tax was withheld at source.
17 Société Générale applied to the Swedish Tax Authority for a refund of the tax thus withheld. It claimed in support of its application that that taxation was an unlawful restriction on the free movement of capital since it was loss-making and that a Swedish company in a comparable situation would not have been subject to such taxation.
18 The tax authority rejected Société Générale’s application for a refund on the ground that the loss on which it relied had not been calculated in accordance with Swedish tax rules.
19 Société Générale then brought an action before the Förvaltningsrätten i Falun (Administrative Court, Falun, Sweden), which dismissed the action. In that regard, the court found that Société Générale had produced French tax return forms, both for itself and for the group of companies to which it belongs, and that it was apparent from those forms that all those companies had recorded significant tax losses in France during the tax year in question. It held, however, that it did not follow from those documents that the loss relied on by Société Générale was equivalent to one which a Swedish company would have had in such a situation. Société Générale had therefore failed to demonstrate, by calculating the result of the tax group as a whole in accordance with Swedish tax rules, that it was in a situation comparable to that of a loss-making Swedish company.
20 Société Générale subsequently brought an action before the Högsta förvaltningsdomstolen (Supreme Administrative Court, Sweden), which is the referring court.
21 That court observes that the Court of Justice found, in the judgments of 22 November 2018, Sofina and Others (C‑575/17, ‘the judgment in Sofina’, EU:C:2018:943), and of 19 December 2024, Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) (C‑601/23, ‘the judgment in Credit Suisse Securities (Europe)’, EU:C:2024:1048), that the application of withholding tax to dividends paid to a loss-making non-resident company, while a resident company is not taxed so long as it remains loss-making, was contrary to the free movement of capital.
22 In the present case, both Société Générale and the group of companies of which it is the parent company recorded significant tax losses in France during the tax year at issue. However, Société Générale did not carry out a calculation of the results of the legal entities belonging to that group in accordance with Swedish tax rules, with the result that it was refused a refund of the withholding tax.
23 In that regard, the referring court asks whether the Member State in which the dividends are paid may require a non-resident company, in order to show that it is loss-making, to recalculate its results in accordance with the underlying tax rules applicable in that Member State.
24 In addition, a further question arises as to whether, where the non-resident company is subject to consolidated taxation, the Member State in which the dividends are paid may require that the results of the group of companies of which that company forms part be taken into account as a whole in order to determine whether that company is in a situation objectively comparable to that of a loss-making Swedish company.
25 The referring court states, in that context, that even though the rules contained in the Law on Income Tax in respect of intra-group transfers allow for the possibility, under certain conditions, of profit and loss compensation within a group of undertakings, the mechanism of consolidated taxation to which Société Générale is subject in France does not exist in Sweden.
26 In those circumstances, the Högsta förvaltningsdomstolen (Supreme Administrative Court) decided to stay the proceedings and to refer the following questions to the Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling:
‘(1) Is it compatible with Article 63 [TFEU] for a State of taxation at source to require a non-resident company, which is subject to taxation at source on dividends and which claims that it is in a situation that is objectively comparable to that of a resident loss-making company, to show that circumstance by recalculating its taxable profit or loss in accordance with the rules applied by the State of taxation at source to taxation on the revenue of resident companies?
(2) If the non-resident company is subject to consolidated taxation, is it compatible with Article 63 TFEU for a State of taxation at source to require the profit or loss of the tax group as a whole to be taken into account when determining whether the company is in a situation that is objectively comparable to that of a resident loss-making company?
(3) Is the reply to question 2 affected if the State of taxation at source does not have rules on consolidated taxation but by contrast does have rules on intra-group transfers which, in certain circumstances, make profit and loss compensation within the group possible?’
Consideration of the questions referred
27 By its questions, which it is appropriate to examine together, the referring court asks, in essence, whether Article 63 TFEU must be interpreted as precluding the practice of the tax authority of a Member State of requiring a non-resident company which belongs to a group of companies which is subject to consolidated taxation in its Member State of residence and which relies on its loss-making situation in order to obtain a refund of the withholding tax levied on dividends received from a company resident in the first Member State, to provide proof of that loss-making situation by systematically recalculating its taxable results in accordance with the rules applied by the first Member State for the taxation of resident companies.
28 The Court is therefore called upon, in the context of the present case, to clarify the conclusions to be drawn from the judgments in Sofina and in Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) as regards the concept of a ‘restriction on the movement of capital’ for the purposes of Article 63(1) TFEU, including as regards the objective comparability of a cross-border situation with a domestic situation and the proportionality of a practice of the national tax authority vis-à-vis a non-resident company belonging to a group of companies which is subject to consolidated taxation in its Member State of residence.
Whether there is a restriction on the free movement of capital
29 It should be observed at the outset that although direct taxation falls within their competence, Member States must exercise that competence consistently with EU law and particularly the fundamental freedoms guaranteed by the FEU Treaty (see, to that effect, judgments of 14 February 1995, Schumacker, C‑279/93, EU:C:1995:31, paragraph 21; of 25 October 2012, Commission v Belgium, C‑387/11, EU:C:2012:670, paragraph 36; and of 30 October 2025, Attal et Associés, C‑321/24, EU:C:2025:836, paragraph 27 and the case-law cited).
30 In that context, it must be stated that, as is apparent from the first subparagraph of Article 3(3) TEU, read in conjunction with Article 26(2) TFEU, one of the main objectives of the European Union is to establish an internal market, comprising an area without internal frontiers. The fundamental freedoms are the cornerstones of the internal market (see, to that effect, judgment of 1 August 2025, Royal Football Club Seraing, C‑600/23, EU:C:2025:617, paragraph 89) and must be interpreted in the light of that objective (see, to that effect, judgments of 5 October 1994, Commission v France, C‑381/93, EU:C:1994:370, paragraph 17, and of 11 December 2014, Commission v Spain, C‑678/11, EU:C:2014:2434, paragraph 38 and the case-law cited).
31 Accordingly, as regards the free movement of capital, in accordance with the settled case-law of the Court, Article 63(1) TFEU lays down a general prohibition on restrictions on the movement of capital between Member States and between Member States and third countries (judgment of 2 March 2023, PrivatBank and Others, C‑78/21, EU:C:2023:137, paragraph 26 and the case-law cited).
32 The concept of ‘restriction’, for the purposes of that provision, includes State measures which are discriminatory in nature in that they establish, directly or indirectly, a difference in treatment between domestic and cross-border movements of capital which does not correspond to an objective difference in circumstances, and which are therefore liable to deter natural or legal persons from other Member States or third countries from carrying out cross-border movements of capital (see, to that effect, judgment of 2 March 2023, PrivatBank and Others, C‑78/21, EU:C:2023:137, paragraphs 48 and 49 and the case-law cited).
33 Specifically, the less favourable treatment by a Member State of dividends paid to non-resident companies, compared to the treatment of dividends paid to resident companies, is thus liable to deter companies established in a Member State other than that first Member State from pursuing investments in that same first Member State and, consequently, amounts to a restriction of the free movement of capital, prohibited, in principle, under Article 63 TFEU (see, to that effect, judgments of 8 November 2007, Amurta, C‑379/05, EU:C:2007:655, paragraph 28, and of 2 June 2016, Pensioenfonds Metaal en Techniek, C‑252/14, EU:C:2016:402, paragraph 28 and the case-law cited).
34 In that regard, the existence of a restriction may arise not only from measures establishing substantive conditions in order to be able to benefit from a tax advantage, but also from measures providing for the proof to be supplied by non-resident companies for that purpose (see judgment of 27 November 2025, Santander Renta Variable España Pensiones, Fondo de Pensiones, C‑525/24, EU:C:2025:922, paragraph 37 and the case-law cited).
35 On the other hand, the disadvantages that may result from the parallel exercise of the tax powers of the various Member States do not constitute restrictions prohibited by the FEU Treaty in so far as such an exercise is not discriminatory (judgments of 25 February 2021, Société Générale, C‑403/19, EU:C:2021:136, paragraph 28, and of 12 March 2026, Marhaux, C‑150/25, EU:C:2026:188, paragraph 37) or, at the very least, they are not liable to prohibit or further impede cross-border operations (see, to that effect, judgments of 8 September 2005, Mobistar and Belgacom Mobile, C‑544/03 and C‑545/03, EU:C:2005:518, paragraph 29, and of 17 March 2022, AllianzGI-Fonds AEVN, C‑545/19, EU:C:2022:193, paragraph 36).
36 In the present case, it is apparent from the order for reference that, in order to take account of the requirements arising from the principle of the free movement of capital, as interpreted by the Court in the judgment in Sofina, the Swedish legislature introduced rules, laid down in Paragraphs 28 to 28n of the Law on the Tax on Dividends, which provides that a company established in another Member State may obtain, on request, a deferment for payment of the tax on dividends which it receives from a Swedish company. Under that legislation, the deferral is granted as long as the non-resident company records a loss, calculated in accordance with the rules of Swedish tax law. In addition, if the non-resident company applying for a deferral belongs to a group of companies which is subject to consolidated taxation of revenue in its State of establishment, the extent of the deferral is to be calculated by reference to the results of all the companies belonging to the group.
37 It is also apparent from the order for reference that although that legislation, which entered into force on 1 January 2020, is not applicable ratione temporis to the dispute in the main proceedings, the tax authority requires Société Générale to provide the evidence referred to in that law in order for it to be granted a refund of the withholding tax levied on the dividends which it has received. Accordingly, Société Générale is to recalculate, in accordance with the rules of Swedish tax law, its own taxable results and those of the group of companies to which it belongs and which is subject to consolidated taxation in France, the Member State in which it is resident.
38 It follows that it is possible in Sweden for loss-making, non-resident companies, just like resident companies, to avoid the immediate imposition of tax on the dividends they receive. However, that possibility is made subject to providing proof of that loss-making situation via a reckoning of the taxable results of those non-resident companies in accordance with the rules of Swedish tax law.
39 Consequently, in order to avoid the immediate imposition of tax on dividends which they receive or to obtain a refund of withholding tax, non-resident companies, which are required to determine their taxable results in accordance with the legislation of their Member State of residence, must also comply with an additional requirement set by the Member State of the source of dividends, since they must systematically recalculate their taxable results in accordance with the rules of Swedish tax law. That additional requirement, which represents an administrative burden only for non-resident companies, is liable further to impede cross-border transactions and constitutes a tax disadvantage for those companies. Moreover, the restrictive and deterrent effect of that disadvantage is expressed in the dispute in the main proceedings in a situation where non-resident companies belong to a group of companies which is subject to consolidated taxation in the Member State of residence.
40 A Member State’s practice of imposing such an additional administrative burden, in order to obtain a refund of withholding tax, is liable to deter non-resident companies from pursuing investments in that Member State and therefore constitutes a restriction on the free movement of capital which is prohibited, in principle, by Article 63(1) TFEU.
41 As is clear from the Court’s settled case-law, taking account of Article 65(1)(a) and (3) TFEU, for national tax legislation which gives rise to a difference in treatment to be regarded as compatible with the provisions of the FEU Treaty on the free movement of capital, that difference in treatment must concern situations which are not objectively comparable or be justified by an overriding reason in the public interest (see, to that effect, judgments of 15 July 2004, Lenz, C‑315/02, EU:C:2004:446, paragraph 27, and of 27 April 2023, L Fund, C‑537/20, EU:C:2023:339, paragraph 45 and the case-law cited).
42 The Court must therefore examine whether the situations at issue in the main proceedings are comparable and, if so, whether there is a justification for an overriding reason in the public interest.
Whether the situations are objectively comparable
43 As the Court has repeatedly held, the comparability of a cross-border situation with an internal situation must be examined having regard to the aim pursued by the national provisions at issue as well as to the purpose and content of those provisions (judgments of 2 June 2016, Pensioenfonds Metaal en Techniek, C‑252/14, EU:C:2016:402, paragraph 48, and of 27 February 2025, Dyrektor Krajowej Informacji Skarbowej (Management form of a UCI), C‑18/23, EU:C:2025:119, paragraph 78 and the case-law cited).
44 However, it is also apparent from the case-law of the Court that where a Member State places the taxation of revenue in a domestic situation and in a cross-border situation on the same footing, in that it chooses to exercise its fiscal powers in both situations, it accepts that, in regard to the detailed rules and conditions relating to that taxation, there is no objective difference between those two situations which could justify different treatment (see, to that effect, judgments of 28 January 1986, Commission v France, 270/83, EU:C:1986:37, paragraph 20, and of 17 July 2014, Nordea Bank Danmark, C‑48/13, EU:C:2014:2087, paragraph 24).
45 That is why the Court has consistently held that once a Member State, either unilaterally or by a convention, imposes a tax charge on the income not only of resident taxpayers but also of non-resident taxpayers in respect of dividends which they receive from a resident company, the position of those non-resident taxpayers becomes comparable to that of the resident taxpayers (see judgments of 12 December 2006, Test Claimants in Class IV of the ACT Group Litigation, C‑374/04, EU:C:2006:773, paragraph 68; of 13 November 2019, College Pension Plan of British Columbia, C‑641/17, EU:C:2019:960, paragraph 66; and of 16 June 2022, ACC Silicones, C‑572/20, EU:C:2022:469, paragraph 40).
46 In the present case, it is apparent from the documents before the Court that, under the Swedish tax legislation applicable to the dispute in the main proceedings, dividends from shares representing less than 10% of the capital of a resident company are, in principle, subject to tax in Sweden, whether they are paid to a resident or to a non-resident company.
47 Accordingly, in the light of the case-law cited in paragraphs 44 and 45 above, it must be held that the situations of those two categories of taxpayer are objectively comparable.
48 That finding cannot be called into question by the arguments put forward by the Swedish and German Governments, supported by the Spanish Government.
49 As regards, in the first place, the evidential requirements at issue in the main proceedings, the Swedish Government submits that, in order to determine whether a non-resident company is in a situation objectively comparable to that of a resident company in terms of there being a tax loss, it is necessary, in principle, to apply the same rules to the income and costs of each company. According to that government, equivalent taxation presupposes substantive comparability, which means that non-resident companies must adjust their accounting methods.
50 In that regard, it should be observed at the outset that the evidence requested from a loss-making non-resident company receiving dividends serves to verify that that company satisfies the conditions for a deferral of tax on those dividends or, as relevant, for obtaining a refund of previously levied withholding tax, so that it may benefit from tax treatment that is comparable to that of a loss-making resident company.
51 As regards the objective of legislation which provides that dividends received by a loss-making company are actually taxed only when that company returns to profit, it should be observed that the order for reference does not contain any information on that issue, but such a right to a deferral of taxation or, as relevant, to a refund of withholding tax generally aims to take the taxpayer’s ability to pay into account. Indeed, a company’s ability to pay is reduced where, at the end of the tax year in which it has received dividends, it records a loss in respect of its overall taxable results.
52 However, with regard to their ability to pay, a resident company and a non-resident company, whose taxable results have each been determined in accordance with the tax-law rules of their respective State of residence, are in the same situation. As the European Commission stated in its written observations, a company’s ability to pay is not affected by the fact that, under different national tax law, it would have had a greater ability to pay and would have recorded profits. By contrast, any recalculation of the taxable results of a non-resident company pertains to a hypothetical situation.
53 It is true, as the Swedish Tax Authority and the Swedish Government submit, that some Member States have more generous rules than others on, for example, tax deductions.
54 However, first, in the absence of harmonisation in this area, it is for each Member State to define, within its tax jurisdiction, the rules relating to the determination of the taxable results of companies that are resident for tax purposes. From the perspective of the company concerned, it is that result which reflects its ability to pay that is of relevance, since it forms the basis for its taxation in its State of residence.
55 Second, while it is true that, because of differences in Member States’ rules, it cannot be ruled out that a company’s taxable results, calculated in accordance with the tax legislation of its State of residence, may be negative, whereas they would have been positive if they had been determined in accordance with the tax legislation of another State, it is just as likely that the opposite situation could arise. The possibility that such cases may exist is the logical consequence of the absence of harmonisation in this area and cannot call into question the objective comparability, with regard to their ability to pay, of a resident and a non-resident company whose taxable results have each been determined in accordance with the rules of the tax law of their respective State of residence.
56 Moreover, the issue of the objective comparability of situations must be distinguished from the issue of whether a company artificially creates the conditions necessary to benefit from a tax deferral or, as relevant, to obtain a refund of withholding tax, which must be examined in the context of the justification for the restriction that has been found.
57 In the second place, the German Government, supported by the Spanish Government, raises fundamental objections to the conclusion drawn by the Court in its judgments in Sofina and in Credit Suisse Securities (Europe), according to which the situation of a loss-making resident company that receives dividends and that of a non-resident company which is also loss-making and receives dividends are objectively comparable.
58 In that regard, it should be stated, first, that the Court, making its findings on the basis of the settled case-law referred to in paragraphs 44 and 45 above, held in its judgments in Sofina and in Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) that two companies, one resident and the other non-resident, which receive dividends, were in objectively comparable situations. Contrary to the submissions of the German and Spanish Governments, that case-law cannot be understood as concerning only the taxation of dividends as such, that is to say, the inclusion of dividends in the taxable base and the tax rate to be applied, or mechanisms intended to avoid a series of charges to tax. It should in fact be found that no limitation to that effect is apparent from the case-law of the Court.
59 Second, as regards the principle of territoriality enshrined in international tax law relied on by the German Government, the Court has held that a Member State’s system under which, for the purpose of calculating the basis of assessment for non-resident taxpayers, only profits and losses arising from their activities in that Member State are taken into account is consistent with that principle (see, to that effect, judgments of 15 May 1997, Futura Participations and Singer, C‑250/95, EU:C:1997:239, paragraphs 21 and 22, and of 15 February 2007, Centro Equestre da Lezíria Grande, C‑345/04, EU:C:2007:96, paragraph 22).
60 However, the powers which Member States are recognised as having by virtue of the principle of territoriality must be exercised in accordance with the principles of EU law (judgment of 1 December 2011, Commission v Belgium, C‑250/08, EU:C:2011:793, paragraph 48), which include, in particular, the principle of proportionality. Consequently, an argument based on the principle of territoriality is not such as to call into question the objectively comparable nature of a domestic situation and a cross-border situation, but must be assessed in the context of examining whether the national legislation at issue is justified, which presupposes that it is proportionate (see, to that effect, judgments of 13 December 2005, Marks & Spencer, C‑446/03, ‘the judgment in Marks & Spencer’, EU:C:2005:763, paragraphs 39, 40 and 53, and of 31 May 2018, Hornbach-Baumarkt, C‑382/16, EU:C:2018:366, paragraph 40).
61 It is to that effect that, in its judgments in Sofina (paragraphs 56 to 64) and in Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) (paragraphs 70 to 78), the Court examined the justification for the national legislation at issue in the cases which gave rise to those judgments in the light of the maintenance of the balanced allocation of powers of taxation between the Member States, a justification ground that is an offshoot of the principle of territoriality (see, to that effect, judgment of 24 February 2022, Viva Telecom Bulgaria, C‑257/20, EU:C:2022:125, paragraphs 110 and 111).
62 Third, relying on the judgment of 17 September 2015, Miljoen and Others (C‑10/14, C‑14/14 and C‑17/14, EU:C:2015:608, paragraph 59), the German Government submits that, for the purposes of comparing the tax burden linked to the receipt of dividends between resident and non-resident companies, only expenses directly linked to the actual payment of the dividends in question must be taken into account.
63 However, that case-law is not relevant. In fact, it concerns the possibility of deducting certain expenses from taxable dividends and, therefore, as the Advocate General observed in point 35 of his Opinion, the determination of the basis of assessment of the tax on dividends, whereas the present case concerns the possibility of deferring payment of that tax.
64 Having regard to all of the foregoing, the restriction on the free movement of capital resulting from a practice such as that at issue in the main proceedings concerns objectively comparable situations.
Justification by an overriding reason in the public interest
65 According to settled case-law of the Court, a restriction on the free movement of capital may be permitted if it is justified by overriding reasons relating to the public interest, is suitable for securing the attainment of the objective which it pursues and does not go beyond what is necessary in order to attain that objective (judgment of 27 April 2023, L Fund, C‑537/20, EU:C:2023:339, paragraph 66 and the case-law cited).
66 The Swedish Government submits that, on the assumption that the practice at issue in the main proceedings amounts to a restriction on the free movement of capital, it is justified, in the first place, by the need to maintain a balanced allocation of powers of taxation between the Member States and the coherence of the national tax system.
67 More specifically, the government submits that Sweden cannot impose tax on the whole of the tax result of a non-resident company receiving Swedish dividends, since the power of taxation is limited to the value created within Swedish companies and distributed in the form of dividends. An obligation to grant a tax deferral to a non-resident company whose results have been calculated in accordance with the tax legislation of its Member State of residence would mean Sweden would have to take account of circumstances which do not fall within its power of taxation, which would be incompatible with the implied symmetry of a balanced allocation of powers of taxation between Member States.
68 In that regard, it is apparent from the judgments in Sofina (paragraphs 56 to 64) and in Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) (paragraphs 70 to 78) that national legislation which makes dividends paid to a loss-making non-resident company subject to immediate and definitive taxation, whereas those paid to a resident company in the same situation are actually taxed only when the latter again makes a profit, cannot be justified by the need to maintain the balanced allocation of powers of taxation between the Member States. Nor, for the same reasons, may a national administrative practice, which imposes an additional administrative burden on non-resident companies wishing to benefit from the tax advantage at issue, which does not have to be borne by resident companies, be justified by that need.
69 As regards the need to maintain the cohesion of the national tax system, it is apparent from the Court’s case-law that, for such an argument to succeed, a direct link must be established between the tax advantage concerned and the offsetting of that advantage by a particular tax levy (the judgment in Credit Suisse Securities (Europe), paragraph 80 and the case-law cited). However, in the present case, the Swedish Government has not established that the tax advantage granted to resident companies is offset by a particular tax levy linked to that advantage.
70 In the second place, the Swedish Government refers to combating tax evasion and tax avoidance. According to that government, if the taxable results of a non-resident company receiving dividends of Swedish origin are not recalculated in accordance with the rules of Swedish legislation, the withholding tax provided for by that legislation could be avoided by transferring shareholdings and, therefore, the right to dividends, to a loss-making company acquired specifically for that purpose.
71 In that regard, it should be borne in mind that the prevention of tax fraud is an overriding reason relating to the public interest, capable of justifying a restriction on the exercise of freedom of movement guaranteed by the FEU Treaty (judgment of 4 October 2024, Staatssecretaris van Financiën (Interest in respect of an intra-group loan)), C‑585/22, EU:C:2024:822, paragraph 55 and the case-law cited).
72 It must also be observed that the tax authorities of a Member State are entitled to require the taxpayer to provide such proof as they may consider necessary in order to determine whether the conditions for a tax advantage have been met and, consequently, whether or not to grant that advantage. The content, the form and the degree of detail which the information submitted by the taxpayer must satisfy are determined by the Member State conferring such an advantage in order to enable it to levy the tax properly (see, to that effect, judgments of 15 May 1997, Futura Participations and Singer, C‑250/95, EU:C:1997:239, paragraph 43; of 30 January 2020, Köln-Aktienfonds Deka, C‑156/17, EU:C:2020:51, paragraph 61 and the case-law cited; and of 27 November 2025, Santander Renta Variable España Pensiones, Fondo de Pensiones, C‑525/24, EU:C:2025:922, paragraph 52).
73 Accordingly, as regards the context of the case in the main proceedings, the Court has already stated that, first, it is the duty of non-resident companies to provide the relevant evidence to allow the tax authorities of the Member State of taxation to determine that the conditions for benefiting from a tax deferral or, as relevant, for obtaining a refund of withholding tax have been met and that, second, those authorities are in a position to check the accuracy of that evidence by means of the mutual assistance mechanisms existing between the authorities of the Member States (see the judgments in Sofina, paragraphs 72 and 73, and in Credit Suisse Securities (Europe), paragraphs 64 and 65).
74 That evidence includes, in particular, that which may reasonably be required in order to establish that the non-resident company concerned is indeed loss-making and that the conditions necessary to benefit from a tax deferral or, as relevant, to obtain a refund of withholding tax have not been created artificially. It is in fact important to observe that, in accordance with the general principle of EU law prohibiting abusive practices, EU law cannot be relied on for abusive or fraudulent ends (see, to that effect, judgment of 26 February 2019, T Danmark and Y Denmark, C‑116/16 and C‑117/16, EU:C:2019:135, paragraph 70 and the case-law cited).
75 However, in order not to make it impossible or excessively difficult for a non-resident taxpayer to obtain a tax advantage, it cannot be required to produce documents which comply in all respects with the form and degree of detail of the documentary evidence laid down in the legislation of the Member State conferring that advantage if the documents provided by that taxpayer do enable that Member State to ascertain, clearly and precisely, that the conditions for obtaining the tax advantage in question have been met (see, to that effect, judgments of 30 January 2020, Köln-Aktienfonds Deka, C‑156/17, EU:C:2020:51, paragraph 62 and the case-law cited, and of 27 November 2025, Santander Renta Variable España Pensiones, Fondo de Pensiones, C‑525/24, EU:C:2025:922, paragraph 53).
76 Even assuming that the obligation imposed on non-resident companies systematically to recalculate their taxable results is regarded as appropriate for the purpose of preventing tax evasion and tax avoidance, that obligation in any event goes beyond what is necessary to attain that objective. As the Advocate General observed in point 53 of his Opinion, such a requirement is based on a principle of generalised suspicion of fraud and not on evidence suggesting that fraud or an artificial arrangement intended to avoid payment of dividend tax exists.
77 Furthermore, owing to the considerable administrative burden which it entails, the obligation to recalculate taxable results is liable to make it excessively difficult for a non-resident company to benefit from a deferral of taxation or, as relevant, to obtain a refund of withholding tax.
78 In the light of all of the foregoing, the practice of the tax authorities at issue, which requires that the taxable results of non-resident companies be systematically recalculated, without providing for the possibility for those companies to provide documents enabling those authorities to ascertain, clearly and precisely, that the conditions for obtaining a tax advantage have been met, constitutes a disproportionate measure.
79 Furthermore, as regards the obligation imposed on a non-resident company belonging to a group of companies in its Member State of residence which is subject to consolidated taxation in that Member State, to recalculate systematically the result of such a group in its entirety, it should be added that, in view of the grounds set out in paragraphs 76 to 78 above, such an obligation must, all the more so, be regarded as disproportionate.
80 It is irrelevant in that regard that the legislation of the Member State from which the dividends are paid does not provide for consolidated taxation, but has rules on intra-group transfers which, under certain conditions, make profit and loss compensation within the group possible. For the same grounds as set out in paragraphs 76 to 79 above, that Member State cannot require a non-resident company, which belongs to a group and which is subject to consolidated taxation in its Member State of residence, to recalculate its consolidated results in line with the Swedish rules on intra-group transfers.
81 The conclusion in paragraph 78 above is not called into question by the German Government’s reference to the case-law arising from the judgment in Marks & Spencer to the effect that, when a company is taxed in a Member State, the losses incurred by that company abroad must be taken into account only exceptionally, namely in the case of final losses.
82 In that regard, it should be observed that, in paragraphs 43 to 51 of the judgment in Marks & Spencer, the Court held that a restriction on the freedom of establishment which limits the right of a resident company to deduct the losses of a foreign subsidiary, whereas it may deduct the losses of a resident subsidiary, is justified by the need to maintain the balanced allocation of the power to impose taxes between the Member States, to prevent the risk of losses being used twice, and the risk of tax avoidance. However, it follows from paragraph 55 of that judgment that such a restriction is disproportionate in a situation where those losses are final in nature.
83 However, as with the cases which gave rise to the judgments in Sofina and in Credit Suisse Securities (Europe), the present case does not concern the deduction of foreign losses, but the determination of the point in time when the Member State in which the dividends are paid may exercise its right to tax income that is generated in its territory (see, to that effect, the judgments in Sofina, paragraph 59, and in Credit Suisse Securities (Europe), paragraph 75).
84 Lastly, as regards the reservations expressed by the German Government at the hearing, related to the fact that the rules in the Treaty on the free movement of capital also apply to the movement of capital between the Member States and third countries, it should be observed that the free movement of capital between Member States and third countries is not at issue in the present case (see, to that effect, judgments of 7 September 2004, Manninen, C‑319/02, EU:C:2004:484, paragraph 51, and of 18 December 2007, A, C‑101/05, EU:C:2007:804, paragraph 60).
85 Having regard to all the foregoing considerations, the answer to the questions referred is that Article 63 TFEU must be interpreted as precluding the practice of the tax authority of a Member State of requiring a non-resident company which belongs to a group of companies which is subject to consolidated taxation in its Member State of residence and which relies on its loss-making situation in order to obtain a refund of the withholding tax levied on dividends received from a company resident in the first Member State to provide proof of that loss-making situation by systematically recalculating its taxable results in accordance with the rules applied by the first Member State for the taxation of resident companies.
Costs
86 Since these proceedings are, for the parties to the main proceedings, a step in the action pending before the referring court, the decision on costs is a matter for that court. Costs incurred in submitting observations to the Court, other than the costs of those parties, are not recoverable.
On those grounds, the Court (Grand Chamber) hereby rules:
Article 63 TFEU must be interpreted as precluding the practice of the tax authority of a Member State of requiring a non-resident company which belongs to a group of companies which is subject to consolidated taxation in its Member State of residence and which relies on its loss-making situation in order to obtain a refund of the withholding tax levied on dividends received from a company resident in the first Member State to provide proof of that loss-making situation by systematically recalculating its taxable results in accordance with the rules applied by the first Member State for the taxation of resident companies.
[Signatures]
* Language of the case: Swedish.