Details
ECLI
Source
Decision form
Issue date
Last update
File mark
Court
Jurisdiction
Judge
Žiadne známe citácie.
62022CO0256_en.html
HTML · 12.73 KB
No categories available
62022CO0256
ORDER OF THE COURT (Tenth Chamber)
5 November 2026 (*)
In Case C‑256/22 P-DEP,
APPLICATION for taxation of recoverable costs under Article 145 of the Rules of Procedure of the Court of Justice, brought on 6 July 2026,
European Central Bank (ECB), represented by M. Puidokas and E. Yoo, acting as Agents,
applicant,
v
Pilatus Bank plc, established in Ta’Xbiex (Malta),
defendant,
THE COURT (Tenth Chamber),
composed of E. Regan, acting as President of the Chamber, J. Passer (Rapporteur) and D. Gratsias, Judges,
Advocate General: J. Kokott,
Registrar: V. Di Bucci,
having regard to the written procedure,
after hearing the Advocate General,
makes the following
Order
1 The present case concerns the taxation of costs incurred by the European Central Bank (ECB) in Cases T‑27/19 and C‑256/22 P.
2 By judgment of 2 February 2022, Pilatus Bank and Pilatus Holding v ECB (T‑27/19, EU:T:2022:46), the General Court of the European Union dismissed the action brought by Pilatus Bank plc and by Pilatus Holding Ltd. seeking annulment of the decision of the ECB of 2 November 2018 withdrawing the authorisation of Pilatus Bank to take up the business of a credit institution. By that judgment, the General Court also ordered Pilatus Bank and Pilatus Holding to pay the costs incurred by the ECB, in accordance with the form of order sought by the ECB.
3 By an appeal brought on 12 April 2022, under Article 56 of the Statute of the Court of Justice of the European Union, Pilatus Bank asked the Court of Justice to set aside that judgment. Pilatus Holding, for its part, did not bring an appeal against that judgment.
4 By judgment of 8 February 2024, Pilatus Bank v ECB (C‑256/22 P, EU:C:2024:125), the Court of Justice set aside that judgment on the ground that, in essence, the General Court had erred in law by failing to determine of its own motion whether the authority conferred by Pilatus Bank on its lawyer was lawful. Moreover, by that judgment, the Court of Justice dismissed the action brought in Case T‑27/19 as inadmissible, inasmuch as that action had been brought by Pilatus Bank. Last, since Pilatus Bank had been unsuccessful and the ECB had applied for Pilatus Bank to be ordered to pay the costs, both at first instance and on appeal, the Court ordered Pilatus Bank to bear its own costs and to pay the costs incurred by the ECB in both of those sets of proceedings.
5 By letters dated 22 April, 24 July, 2 October and 26 November 2025, the ECB requested the reimbursement of expenses necessarily incurred by it for the purposes of both of those sets of proceedings.
6 Since no reply was given to those letters and therefore no agreement was reached between the parties on the amount of recoverable costs relating to those sets of proceedings, the ECB lodged the present application for taxation of costs.
Forms of order sought by the parties
7 The ECB claims that the Court should fix the amount of recoverable costs at EUR 1 037.66.
8 Pilatus Bank did not respond to that claim within the time limit set for that purpose.
Arguments of the parties
9 In its application for taxation of costs, the ECB states that the amount of recoverable costs that it asks the Court to fix corresponds to the total gross amount of expenses related to travel and to accommodation in hotel rooms for the two agents who represented it at the hearing that was organised by the General Court during the proceedings at first instance on 26 February 2021. The ECB provides, as annexes to that application, documents confirming that those expenses were actually incurred.
10 Furthermore, the ECB requests that default interest be applied to the amount of those expenses, from the date of service of the order of the Court of Justice until the date of actual payment of the costs owed, calculated on the basis of the rate applied by the ECB to its main refinancing operations in force on the first calendar day of the month in which the deadline for payment falls, increased by three and a half percentage points.
Findings of the Court
11 In accordance with Article 144(b) of the Rules of Procedure of the Court of Justice, which is applicable to appeal proceedings in accordance with Article 184(1) of those rules, expenses necessarily incurred by the parties for the purpose of the proceedings, in particular the travel and subsistence expenses and the remuneration of agents, advisers or lawyers are to be regarded as recoverable costs.
12 According to settled case-law, recoverable costs are to be limited, first, to expenses incurred for the purposes of the proceedings before the Court, with the exception of the stage preceding those proceedings, and, second, to expenses necessarily incurred for those purposes (orders of 3 October 2018, Orange v Commission, C‑486/15 P‑DEP, EU:C:2018:824, paragraph 26, and of 10 July 2026, Koiviston Auto Helsinki v Commission, C‑697/22 P‑DEP, EU:C:2026:576, paragraph 33).
13 The same applies in relation to Article 140(b) of the Rules of Procedure of the General Court (order of 10 July 2026, Koiviston Auto Helsinki v Commission, C‑697/22 P-DEP, EU:C:2026:576, paragraph 34).
14 In the absence of any provision of EU law laying down fee-scales or concerning necessary hours of work, the Court must make an unfettered assessment of the facts of the case, taking into account, in relation to the content of the application for taxation of costs submitted to it in a particular case, the purpose and nature of the proceedings, their significance from the point of view of EU law as well as the difficulties presented by the case, the amount of work generated by the proceedings for the agents and advisers involved and the financial interest which the parties had in the proceedings (orders of 30 May 2018, Simba Toys v EUIPO and Seven Towns, C‑30/15 P‑DEP, EU:C:2018:353, paragraph 23, and of 10 July 2026, Koiviston Auto Helsinki v Commission, C‑697/22 P‑DEP, EU:C:2026:576, paragraph 36).
15 Furthermore, in fixing the recoverable costs, the Court takes account of all the circumstances of the case up to the making of the order on taxation of the costs, including the expenses necessarily incurred in relation to the taxation of costs proceedings (orders of 30 May 2018, Simba Toys v EUIPO and Seven Towns, C‑30/15 P‑DEP, EU:C:2018:353, paragraph 24, and of 10 July 2026, Koiviston Auto Helsinki v Commission, C‑697/22 P‑DEP, EU:C:2026:576, paragraph 37).
16 In the present case, in the first place, the expenses covered by the application for taxation of costs in respect of the proceedings at first instance and the appeal proceedings relate entirely and exclusively to the travel and subsistence expenses of the two agents who represented the ECB at the hearing that was organised at first instance, as is apparent from paragraph 9 of the present order.
17 Those expenses are among the expenses that are recoverable under Article 144(b) of the Rules of Procedure.
18 Furthermore, those expenses, the total gross amount of which is EUR 1 037.66, do not appear to be disproportionate. First, that amount does not appear to be unreasonable, inasmuch as it corresponds to the total amount of expenses related to travel to the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg and accommodation in hotel rooms for the two agents appointed by the ECB to represent it in the proceedings at first instance. Second, representation in the present case by two agents may itself be regarded as necessary, taking into account the various, sometimes complex, legal issues raised by the 11 pleas in law relied on by Pilatus Bank in its action for annulment. In that regard, it should, moreover, be noted that the General Court assigned that action for annulment to a chamber sitting in extended composition.
19 Last, the ECB did not indicate that it had incurred recoverable costs in respect of the taxation of costs proceedings.
20 In the light of those factors, the costs recoverable by the ECB from Pilatus Bank, relating both to the proceedings at first instance and to the appeal proceedings, including the present taxation of costs proceedings, can be fixed on an equitable basis at EUR 1 037.66.
21 As regards, in the second place, the default interest requested by the ECB, for the period from the date of service of the present order until the date of payment of the total amount owed, the interest rate applicable must be set on the basis of the rate applied by the ECB to its main refinancing operations in force on the first calendar day of the month in which the deadline for payment falls, increased by three and a half percentage points (see, to that effect, orders of 9 November 2023, Hypo Vorarlberg Bank v SRB, C‑663/20 P‑DEP, EU:C:2023:862, paragraph 41, and of 8 July 2025, Land Rheinland-Pfalz v Deutsche Lufthansa, C‑453/19 P‑DEP, EU:C:2025:539, paragraph 60).
On those grounds, the Court (Tenth Chamber) hereby orders:
The total amount of costs to be reimbursed by Pilatus Bank plc to the European Central Bank (ECB) in Cases T‑27/19 and C‑256/22 P is fixed at EUR 1 037.66, to which shall be added default interest applicable from the date of service of the present order until the date of payment of the total amount owed, at a rate equal to that applied by the ECB to its main refinancing operations in force on the first day of the month in which the deadline for payment falls, increased by three and a half percentage points.
Luxembourg, 5 November 2026.
V. Di Bucci
E. Regan
Registrar
Acting as President of the Chamber
* Language of the case: English.