Details
ECLI
Source
Decision form
Issue date
Last update
File mark
Court
Jurisdiction
Žiadne známe citácie.
62025CC0287_en.html
HTML · 68.74 KB
No categories available
62025CC0287
Provisional text
OPINION OF ADVOCATE GENERAL
KOKOTT
delivered on 22 October 2026 (1)
Joined Cases C‑287/25 to C‑289/25
OPmobility and Others
(Request for a preliminary ruling from the Conseil d’État (Council of State, France))
I. Introduction
1 The line of case-law established by the judgment in Marks & Spencer (2) has occupied the Court for more than 20 years. In that judgment, the Court had ruled that, on the basis of the freedom of establishment under Articles 49 and 54 TFEU (formerly Articles 43 and 48 EC), Member States must, under certain conditions, take into account ‘final’ losses of foreign subsidiaries in taxing domestic parent companies. The present request for a preliminary ruling from the Conseil d’État (Council of State, France) concerns the application of that case-law in France.
2 The fundamental issue is whether the fact that French tax law does not provide for final losses of non-resident subsidiaries to be taken into account in the context of taxation of a parent company resident in France is compatible with the freedom of establishment. By contrast, under French law, losses of resident subsidiaries may, under certain conditions, reduce the tax base of a domestic parent company.
3 The first question referred for a preliminary ruling relates to the criterion of objective comparability, which is to be examined in the context of the freedom of establishment in accordance with the Court’s case-law. The Conseil d’État (Council of State) wishes to know whether parent companies with resident subsidiaries and those with non-resident subsidiaries are really in comparable situations if the State in which the parent company is resident waives the right of taxation in respect of non-resident subsidiaries under a double taxation convention (DTC) or under its national law.
4 The second question referred for a preliminary ruling concerns the justification of a restriction on the freedom of establishment where final losses of non-resident subsidiaries are not taken into account. The request for a preliminary ruling arises because French tax law provides for joint taxation of multiple group companies only in the case of a tax-integrated group or entity. However, only domestic companies are able to form such entities.
5 The questions referred to the Court in this case fundamentally call into question the line of case-law established since the judgment in Marks & Spencer. If there is no objective comparability between parent companies with resident subsidiaries and those with non-resident subsidiaries, which is to be examined in the context of the first question, a restriction on the freedom of establishment would be precluded, regardless of the existence of final losses. The ‘Marks & Spencer exception’ would then no longer appear to apply in most cases. The second question offers the Court an opportunity to harmonise its case-law relating to cross-border use of losses with its case-law concerning the formation of a single tax entity between parent companies and subsidiaries. (3)
II. Legal framework
A. International law
6 Double taxation conventions exist between France and the Member States of each of the subsidiaries concerned, namely Belgium, (4) Latvia (5) and Slovakia. (6) Those conventions provide that profits of a company of a Contracting State are taxable only in the State in which it is resident. It is otherwise only if the company carries on its business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated there. In that case, the company’s profits, in so far as they can be attributed to that permanent establishment, are taxable in the other Contracting State.
B. European Union law
7 The requests for a preliminary ruling concern the freedom of establishment of companies laid down in Articles 49 and 54 TFEU.
C. National law
8 Article 209 of the French Code général des impôts (General Tax Code; ‘CGI’) provides:
‘I. Subject to the provisions of this Section, profits liable to corporation tax shall be determined … taking into account only profits made in undertakings carried on in France, profits referred to in paragraph I(a), (e), (e bis) and (e ter) of Article 164 B and profits the taxation of which is attributed to France by an international double taxation convention.
…
Subject to the option provided for in Article 220 quinquies, if a loss is sustained during a financial year, it shall be treated as a charge in the following financial year and shall be deducted from the profit recorded for that year up to a maximum amount of EUR 1 000 000 increased by 50% of the amount corresponding to the taxable profit for that year exceeding the first amount. If that profit is insufficient for the deduction to be made in full, the excess loss shall be carried forward under the same conditions to subsequent financial years. The same shall apply to the portion of the excess not eligible for deduction under the first sentence of this subparagraph.’
9 Article 223 A of the CGI provides in particular:
‘I. A company, hereinafter referred to as “parent company”, may render itself the sole party liable for corporation tax due on the overall profits of the group formed by the company itself and the companies of which it is the holder, continuously throughout the financial year, of at least 95% of the capital, directly or indirectly through companies or permanent establishments which are members of the group, hereinafter referred to as “group companies”, or through companies or permanent establishments, hereinafter referred to as “intermediate companies”, in which at least 95% of the capital is held by the parent company continuously throughout the financial year, directly or indirectly through group companies or intermediate companies.
…
III. Only those companies or permanent establishments which have given their consent and whose results are subject to corporation tax under the conditions of the general law or the rules laid down in Article 214 may be members of the group.’
10 Under Article 223 I(1)(a) of the CGI, ‘losses sustained by a company in the group in financial years before it joined the group may … be offset against its profit only within the limits and subject to the conditions laid down in the third subparagraph of Article 209 I.’
III. Facts and main proceedings
A. Case C‑287/25
11 OPmobility (‘OPM’) is a parent company, resident for tax purposes in France, of a tax-integrated group which includes Plastic Omnium Auto Exteriors. In 1997 the latter company established a Belgian subsidiary, Plastic Omnium Automotive NV (‘POA’), in order to construct a factory in Belgium and to supply local customers there.
12 Because of the poor economic situation on the local automotive market, POA was liquidated in 2015. In that year it recorded losses of EUR 18 435 612.
13 OPM applied for those losses to be taken into account, on the basis of the Court’s ruling in Marks & Spencer, in determining the group’s result for the financial year 2015. It claimed that, if POA had been resident in France, it would have fulfilled all the conditions for inclusion in the tax consolidation group formed by OPM.
14 The tax authorities rejected its application. However, the Tribunal administratif de Montreuil (Administrative Court, Montreuil, France) and the Cour administrative d’appel de Paris (Administrative Court of Appeal, Paris, France) each upheld the action brought against that decision by judgments of 11 February 2021 and of 15 December 2023. The case is now before the Conseil d’État (Council of State).
B. Cases C‑288/25 and C‑289/25
15 Société Générale (‘SG’) is a parent company, resident for tax purposes in France, of a tax-integrated group which includes Société Générale Consumer Finance (‘SGCF’). In 2005 and 2006, SGCF acquired the entire capital of the Slovak company Essox and the Latvian company Inserviss Group (‘IG’).
16 In 2013, Essox and IG were liquidated in view of the considerable deterioration in their financial situation. Losses of EUR 9 049 114 (Essox) and EUR 35 262 226 (IG) were recorded for the two companies, which SG considers to be final.
17 SG thereupon applied for the losses of Essox and IG to be taken into account, on the basis of the Court’s ruling in Marks & Spencer, in determining its group’s result for the financial years 2013 and 2014. It claimed in that regard that – except for the condition of being subject to French corporation tax – Essox and IG had fulfilled all the conditions for membership of the tax-integrated group formed by SG.
18 The tax authorities rejected the applications. The Tribunal administratif de Montreuil (Administrative Court, Montreuil) confirmed the rejections by judgments of 11 February 2021 and 28 April 2022. The Cour administrative d’appel de Paris (Administrative Court of Appeal, Paris) granted the appeal lodged by SG in respect of the losses sustained by IG, but dismissed the appeal in respect of the losses sustained by Essox. The cases are now before the Conseil d’État (Council of State).
IV. Requests for a preliminary ruling and procedure before the Court
19 By orders of 15 April 2025, lodged at the Court Registry on 16 April 2025, the Conseil d’État (Council of State) stayed the proceedings and referred the following questions for a preliminary ruling in each of the three cases:
(1) (a) Is the fact that the State in which a company at the head of an integrated tax group is resident has waived, pursuant to the rules on the territoriality of tax laid down in its national law, the exercise of its power to tax the profits of the non-resident subsidiary of that company situated in another Member State capable of calling into question the objectively comparable nature of the situation of a resident parent company wishing to form a single tax entity with a resident subsidiary and the situation of a resident parent company wishing to form a single tax entity with a non-resident subsidiary in so far as each seeks to benefit from the advantages of the tax integration scheme?
(b) Is the fact that the Member State in which a company at the head of an integrated tax group is resident has waived, pursuant to a double taxation convention, the exercise of its power to tax the profits of the non-resident subsidiary of that company situated in another Member State capable of calling into question the objective comparability of the situation of a resident parent company wishing to form a single tax entity with a resident subsidiary and the situation of a resident parent company wishing to form a single tax entity with a non-resident subsidiary in so far as each seeks to benefit from the advantages of the tax integration scheme?
(2) If the answer to one or other of the parts of the first question is in the negative, does the impossibility, in the context of a tax integration scheme such as that provided for in Article 223 A et seq. of the [General Tax Code], of offsetting against the overall profit of that group the final losses of a non-resident subsidiary of a company in the group constitute one of the rules on the consolidation of profits and losses within the single tax entity, compatible, on that basis alone, with the freedom of establishment, or, on the contrary, must such an impossibility be regarded as the refusal of a tax advantage distinct from the rules on the consolidation of profits and losses within the group, constituting, in itself, a disproportionate restriction incompatible with that freedom?
20 By decision of the President of the Court of Justice of 26 May 2025, Cases C‑287/25, C‑288/25 and C‑289/25 were joined for the purposes of the written and oral parts of the procedure and of the judgment.
21 In the written procedure, OPM, SG, France, Germany and the European Commission submitted observations. They also, together with Finland, took part in the hearing held on 15 September 2026.
V. Assessment
22 The French rules under which only losses of domestic subsidiaries may, under certain conditions, reduce the tax base of a domestic parent company are consistent with the principle of territoriality enshrined in international law, which is also recognised in EU law. Under that principle, the State in which the parent company is resident taxes resident companies on their worldwide profits and non-resident companies solely on the profits from their activities in that State. (7)
23 By its decision in Marks & Spencer, however, the Court departed from that principle: where losses are incurred by a subsidiary which is resident in another Member State and carries on its activity in that State, it is a disproportionate restriction on the freedom of establishment not to take those losses into account for the purposes of taxation in the State in which the parent company is resident, provided all possibilities of claiming those losses in the State in which the subsidiary is established have been exhausted without success and there is also no possibility of those losses being taken into account there in the future. Otherwise, those losses could not be taken into account for tax purposes in either of those two States. Exceptionally, the State in which the parent company is resident is therefore obliged to take the final losses of that non-resident subsidiary into account on a cross-border basis. (8)
24 In subsequent judgments, the Court has increasingly restricted the notion of final losses and recognises the obligation to take them into account only to a very limited extent. (9)
25 The questions asked by the Conseil d’État (Council of State) do not, however, relate to whether final losses exist but, as has already been mentioned, fundamentally call into question the judgment in Marks & Spencer. They are intended to clarify whether domestic and foreign subsidiaries are in a comparable situation when it comes to taking final losses into account (first question) or whether the refusal to take into account such losses of foreign subsidiaries on the basis of the contested French rules is at least justified (second question).
26 In addressing the first question referred for a preliminary ruling, I will briefly show that an obligation to import losses would, in fact, make it more attractive to establish foreign subsidiaries. That could indicate a restriction. I will then explain, however, why the exercise of powers of taxation by the Member States should be the decisive criterion in examining the objective comparability of situations. It follows that, nevertheless, no restriction on the freedom of establishment can be taken to exist in this case.
27 I will therefore explain only in the alternative thereafter, in answering the second question, that in any event the refusal to take final losses into account on a cross-border basis would be justified.
A. First question referred for a preliminary ruling
28 By its first question, the referring court wishes to ascertain whether the situation of a resident parent company wishing to form a single tax entity with a resident subsidiary is objectively comparable with the situation of a resident parent company wishing to form a single tax entity with a non-resident subsidiary. In particular, it is asked whether it is decisive in that respect that the Member State in which the parent company is resident has unilaterally or bilaterally waived its power to tax the profits of the non-resident subsidiary.
1. Interpretation of the question referred for a preliminary ruling
29 OPM and SG point out that the question asked would not allow the main proceedings before the referring court to be decided, since it proceeds on the basis that foreign group companies could not be part of a tax group or entity under French law. However, the applicants have never requested the formation of a single tax entity with their respective non-resident subsidiaries. They merely sought to have the final losses of those subsidiaries taken into account in isolation in France on the basis of the judgment in Marks & Spencer.
30 As the applicants are seeking to have the losses of their non-resident subsidiaries taken into account, it is irrelevant to the answer to the first question, in my view, whether or not the applicants in the main proceedings wished to establish tax integration. The crucial factor is that French law does not provide for losses of non-resident subsidiaries to be taken into account, while that possibility is available to resident subsidiaries, provided they form a single tax entity with their parent company.
31 The first question referred by the Conseil d’État (Council of State) therefore centres on the extent to which the unilateral or bilateral waiver of the power of taxation by the State in which the parent company is resident affects objective comparability.
2. Preliminary remark: restriction on the freedom of establishment
32 The question concerning objective comparability seeks to determine whether the French provisions at issue are compatible with the freedom of establishment enshrined in Article 49 TFEU.
33 Direct taxation, which is the subject of those rules, falls within the competence of Member States. They must, however, exercise that competence in a manner consistent with EU law, in particular having due regard to the fundamental freedoms. (10)
34 The freedom of establishment prohibits restrictions on the freedom of establishment of nationals of a Member State in the territory of another Member State. Furthermore, in conjunction with Article 54 TFEU, the freedom of establishment grants companies or firms formed in accordance with the law of a Member State and having their registered office, central administration or principal place of business within the European Union the right to exercise their activity in other Member States through a subsidiary, branch or agency. (11)
35 Even though, according to their wording, the provisions on freedom of establishment are aimed at ensuring that foreign nationals are treated in the host Member State in the same way as nationals of that State, according to the Court’s settled case-law, they also prohibit the Member State of origin from hindering the establishment in another Member State of one of its nationals or of a company incorporated under its legislation. (12) All measures which prohibit, impede or render less attractive the exercise of that freedom must be regarded as restrictions on the freedom of establishment. (13) Because the freedom of establishment under the first paragraph of Article 49 TFEU expressly includes the setting-up of subsidiaries, France must have regard to the freedom of establishment in the context of taxation of parent companies of non-resident subsidiaries.
36 As Germany explains, France treats parent companies with non-resident subsidiaries differently for tax purposes as regards losses sustained by those subsidiaries from those with resident subsidiaries. The French tax integration rules allow profits and losses of all the companies in the integrated group to be offset and can therefore reduce the group’s tax burden. Tax integration is possible, however, only between resident companies. Non-resident subsidiaries, on the other hand, cannot form a single tax entity with their parent company under French law and, consequently, losses of those subsidiaries are not taken into account for the purposes of taxation of the parent company.
37 That difference in treatment according to the place of establishment of the subsidiary is likely to hinder or make less attractive the formation, acquisition or holding of companies in another Member State and thus the exercise of the freedom of establishment. (14)
38 Such a difference in treatment is permissible, according to settled case-law, only if it concerns situations which are not objectively comparable, or if it is justified by an overriding reason in the public interest proportionate to that objective. (15)
3. The exercise of powers of taxation in accordance with the principle of territoriality as the decisive criterion for objective comparability
39 In examining the comparability of a cross-border situation with a domestic situation, the objective pursued by the national provisions at issue, as well as the purpose and content of those provisions, are crucial. (16)
40 The French legislature has made tax integration of the companies in question a condition for losses of subsidiaries to be able to be taken into account in the taxation of the parent company. The possibility of tax integration is, in turn, available only to companies whose profits are subject to French corporation tax (see Article 223 A(3) of the French CGI). That essentially covers profits and losses made in France (see Article 209(1) of the French CGI).
41 The French rules thus pursue the objective of allowing losses to be taken into account only where it is also possible to tax profits. In that regard, the French legislature exercises its powers of taxation in accordance with the principles of territoriality and symmetry of profits and losses (17) which are recognised in international law.
42 In view of the foregoing, parent companies with resident subsidiaries and those with non-resident subsidiaries are not in objectively comparable situations, since France does not exercise any powers of taxation in respect of non-resident subsidiaries and does not therefore tax their profits. Accordingly, there is also no obligation to take into account losses of non-resident subsidiaries in the State in which the parent company is resident.
43 The fact that the non-exercise of powers of taxation results in the rejection of objective comparability between non-resident and resident taxable persons is also consistent with the Court’s case-law in connection with other tax situations. (18)
44 In the context of cross-border use of losses, the Court has recently ruled along those lines in its judgment in W. The crucial factor in determining the absence of comparability in that case was the fact that the Member State concerned, ‘under a double taxation convention … has waived its power to tax the profits made and losses incurred by such a permanent establishment situated in another Member State’. Accordingly, ‘a resident company which has such an establishment is not in a situation comparable to that of a resident company which has a permanent establishment situated in Germany in the light of the objective of preventing or mitigating the double taxation of profits and, symmetrically, the double taking into account of losses’. (19)
45 That case-law concerns the issue of whether final losses of a non-resident permanent establishment may be taken into account in the State of the company that maintains it. However, the same must hold a fortiori in connection with subsidiaries.
46 Subsidiaries are independent legal persons, unlike permanent establishments. In the exercise of powers of taxation in accordance with the principle of territoriality, they are therefore taxable, in principle, in the State of their residence and not in the State of the parent company. (20) Accordingly, the State of the parent company does not, from the outset, tax the profits which a subsidiary resident in another Member State has generated there. Consequently, there is also no reason to require it to take into account the losses of those subsidiaries. (21)
47 Permanent establishments, on the other hand, are legally dependent entities of a company. They are, in principle, subject to the powers of taxation of the State of that company if that State includes in its taxation the worldwide income of taxable entities situated in it. (22) This does not represent a departure from the principle of territoriality, as non-resident permanent establishments are sufficiently closely connected, through the taxable entities resident in a State, with that State (23) and can therefore be attributed to that State for tax purposes.
48 If the waiver of the right of taxation through a DTC is crucial to the absence of objective comparability between companies with resident permanent establishments and those with non-resident permanent establishments, then a failure to claim taxation in the first place should a fortiori preclude objective comparability between parent companies with resident subsidiaries and those with non-resident subsidiaries.
49 In the judgment in Bevola regarding non-resident permanent establishments, the Court did accept the objective comparability of the situations at issue, even though the Member State had not exercised its powers of taxation. (24) However, it has effectively abandoned that decision by the judgment in W. (25)
4. Bilateral and unilateral waiver of the exercise of powers of taxation
50 In the judgment in W the Court relied, in order to make a distinction with its decision in the judgment in Bevola, on the fact that the Member State had waived its power of taxation by way of a DTC, and not as in the judgment in Bevola unilaterally by way of its national law. (26) I do not consider, however, that the use of a DTC is decisive in examining objective comparability. Rather, as I will explain below, a unilateral waiver of the exercise of powers of taxation must be sufficient, in principle, to preclude comparability.
51 As the Commission rightly points out, a Member State has not definitively waived the power of taxation even in the case of a DTC and the conclusion of a DTC carries no more weight in that sense than a unilateral waiver of the power of taxation in national law. In that case, EU law does not preclude the possibility of a ‘treaty override’, that is, the adoption of a national measure contrary to the provisions of the DTC. (27) In addition, as the applicants submit, DTCs, as international treaties, have the same status in some Member States as ordinary national law. (28) Furthermore, as the Commission and the applicants maintain, it is ultimately irrelevant to the outcome (no taxation of profits and losses of permanent establishments situated abroad) whether that is based purely on national law or on a DTC concluded with another Member State.
52 Even if the Court wished to maintain a distinction in the context of permanent establishments between the waiver of the power of taxation in a DTC or in national law, that distinction could certainly not be convincing in any event in the context of subsidiaries.
53 As has already been discussed, non-resident subsidiaries are independent taxable entities and, consequently, do not, in principle, fall under the powers of taxation of the State in which the parent company is resident in accordance with the principle of territoriality which is recognised in international law. In that connection, it cannot be relevant whether the ‘waiver’ of the exercise of powers of taxation is unilateral or bilateral. In both cases, it merely constitutes confirmation that no liability to tax exists in accordance with the principle of territoriality. (29)
54 The rules on cross-border use of losses of permanent establishments, on the one hand, and of subsidiaries, on the other hand, follow a virtually inverse logic. For permanent establishments as legally dependent entities of a company, which, as such, are subject, in principle, to the powers of taxation of the State in which that company is resident, arrangements must be made to avoid double taxation (and thus also double use of losses). For subsidiaries, by contrast, there is no such risk if, in accordance with the principle of territoriality, they are already taxed only in the State in which they are established. There is therefore no need for regulation of cross-border taxation, as is often implemented for permanent establishments by way of DTCs. Rules on taxation of subsidiaries in DTCs are therefore even less likely than rules on permanent establishments. It would therefore be contradictory, in the case of subsidiaries, to infer merely from the absence of rules in a DTC that domestic and foreign subsidiaries are comparable.
55 Even under the DTCs which France concluded with the three States in which the subsidiaries at issue here are established, France does not tax non-resident subsidiaries in those States (see point 6).
56 In the context of subsidiaries, it is thus crucial solely whether or not the State in which the parent company is resident exercises its powers of taxation. If they are not exercised, as is common, there is no objective comparability.
5. Interim conclusion
57 In summary, having regard to the freedom of establishment, the situation of a resident parent company wishing to have losses of a resident subsidiary taken into account in its taxation is not objectively comparable with the situation of a resident parent company seeking to have losses of a non-resident subsidiary taken into account if, pursuant to the rules on the territoriality of tax or pursuant to a double taxation convention, the State in which the parent companies are resident does not tax the profits of the non-resident subsidiary situated in another Member State.
B. Second question referred for a preliminary ruling
58 Should the Court concur with my view regarding the first question, it is not necessary to answer the second question. I will therefore comment on it only in the alternative.
59 By its second question, the referring court wishes to know whether the rules at issue in this case in Article 223 A et seq. of the French CGI are compatible with the freedom of establishment because they regulate the consolidation of profits and losses within a single tax entity or whether that should be regarded as the refusal of a tax advantage distinct from the rules on the consolidation of profits and losses within the group, constituting, in itself, a disproportionate restriction on the freedom of establishment.
60 That question thus essentially seeks to ascertain how the Court’s rulings in the judgments in Marks & Spencer and in X Holding can be reconciled with one another. In the judgment in Marks & Spencer, the Court regarded the refusal to take into account final losses on a cross-border basis within the framework of a ‘group relief system’ as a disproportionate restriction of the freedom of establishment. (30) In the judgment in X Holding, by contrast, it concluded that the non-applicability of tax integration schemes, and the associated advantage of cross-border offsetting of losses, to non-resident subsidiaries is justified with a view to safeguarding the allocation of the power to impose taxes between the Member States. (31)
61 Some Member States understand the different conclusions in the two judgments to mean that, where there are tax integration schemes which are applicable solely to resident companies, it is not necessary to take losses into account in accordance with the judgment in Marks & Spencer. In such a case, it is always justified not to take into account losses of non-resident subsidiaries, including final losses.
62 The justification of a restriction on the freedom of establishment nevertheless requires, in all cases, the existence of overriding reasons in the public interest, which must be examined in each individual case. In addition, the restriction must be appropriate to ensuring the attainment of the objective in question and not go beyond what is necessary to attain that objective. (32) Although classifying the contested scheme is helpful in order to understand it, it cannot be decisive for the examination of justification to be carried out independently of such classification.
63 Should the Court conclude that the fact that the State in which the parent company is resident has not exercised powers of taxation in respect of non-resident subsidiaries does not in itself preclude the objective comparability of the situations, it would, at least together with the associated objective of maintenance of tax coherence, justify not taking into account final losses of those non-resident subsidiaries in the taxation of the parent company.
1. Grounds for justification
64 France puts forward the maintenance of tax coherence as an overriding reason in the public interest. It argues that the provisions at issue, which allow the formation of a single tax entity only in respect of resident companies, are necessary in order to maintain the coherence of the French tax system. That view is shared by Germany, which also mentions the preservation of the allocation of the power to impose taxes between the Member States and the avoidance of double use of losses as grounds for justification.
65 If final losses exist, however, there is no risk of double use of losses. According to the Court’s case-law, a specific characteristic of final losses is that they can no longer be taken into account in the State in which they were incurred. The avoidance of the risk of double use of losses is therefore ruled out as a ground for justification.
66 On the other hand, the preservation of the allocation of the power to impose taxes between the Member States and the maintenance of tax coherence must be taken into consideration. According to the Court’s settled case-law, they constitute recognised legitimate objectives to justify a restriction on the freedom of establishment. (33)
67 For an argument based on the justification of maintenance of tax coherence to succeed, a direct link must exist between a tax advantage and the offsetting of that advantage by a particular tax levy. The direct nature of the link between the advantage and the levy is assessed in the light of the objective pursued by the tax rules. (34)
68 In the present case, the ground for justification of maintenance of tax coherence is closely connected with the ground for justification of preservation of the allocation of the power to impose taxes between the Member States.
69 Indeed, the advantage of taking into account losses of a subsidiary in calculating the tax base, which is specifically granted through tax integration of domestic companies, is directly offset by the converse disadvantage of profits of those companies being taxed at group level. (35)
70 This is also illustrated in French tax law by the fact that, even where there is tax integration between a resident parent company and its resident subsidiaries, the subsidiaries’ losses can be taken into account only from the date of tax integration. It is not possible to take into account losses incurred before joining the group. That is consistent with the notion of coherence, since profits realised before integration have already been taxed at the level of the subsidiary and, accordingly, can no longer be taken into account.
71 That applies a fortiori to the taking into account of final losses of non-resident subsidiaries. As has already been mentioned, France does not exercise any powers of taxation in respect of non-resident subsidiaries. The Member State therefore does not tax the profits of such companies. Cross-border use of losses of non-resident subsidiaries in isolation would therefore jeopardise both the allocation of the power to impose taxes between the Member States and the coherence of that tax system.
72 As France stresses, the coherence of the French tax system is jeopardised in the case at issue in two respects: first, it is claimed that losses of a non-integrated company should be taken into account. Second, the applicants are seeking the cross-border use of losses which their non-resident subsidiaries have accumulated over several years, whereas integrated companies are able to request that losses be taken into account only from the date of integration.
2. Proportionality
73 It remains to be examined, however, whether not taking into account losses of non-resident subsidiaries pursuant to the French tax integration rules is disproportionate where those losses are final in nature. Does that restriction on the freedom of establishment go beyond what is necessary to preserve the allocation of the power to impose taxes between the Member States and to maintain tax coherence? And should the cross-border use of losses in isolation therefore be possible in such a case for reasons of proportionality?
74 In my view, that is not the case.
75 Not taking into account final losses of foreign subsidiaries in the taxation of the domestic parent company is clearly appropriate to ensuring the allocation of the power to impose taxes between the Member States and the coherence of the French tax integration rules.
76 That approach is also necessary to those objectives, since there are no evident means which are less harmful to the exercise of the freedom of establishment and, at the same time, would attain those objectives equally well.
77 Not taking into account final losses on a cross-border basis is also not disproportionate to the associated restriction on the freedom of establishment.
78 It is true that it would be more attractive for parent companies to exercise their freedom of establishment by way of setting up non-resident subsidiaries if the final losses of those subsidiaries were taken into account in reducing the taxation of the parent company. If that is not possible, setting up or maintaining non-resident subsidiaries entails a greater risk than setting up domestic subsidiaries. However, that is often offset by the advantages of investing abroad, which may even include a lower tax rate.
79 Moreover, the company’s interest in importing losses carries much less weight than the preservation of the allocation of the power to impose taxes between the Member States and the maintenance of the coherence of national tax law.
80 As has already been mentioned, the obligation of the State in which the parent company is resident to take into account final losses of a subsidiary resident in another Member State constitutes an importation of losses which is solely to the detriment of the State in which the parent company is resident. It means, in particular, that that State must bear the consequences of tax-related or other policy decisions by the State in which the subsidiary is established, without being able to influence them, since the losses claimed may be based on special tax schemes in the State in which the subsidiary is established, such as special depreciation schemes. They may, however, also be the result of other policy decisions by the State of establishment which adversely affect the economic situation of the subsidiary. The losses to be imported may thus result from the autonomous organisation of the law, in particular tax law, in other Member States.
81 The tax revenue of the State in which the parent company is resident is thereby reduced on account of the final nature of the losses, without the possibility of any offsetting by taxing future profits of the non-resident subsidiary. (36)
82 By contrast, the State in which the subsidiary is established was able to tax its profits, possibly over several years, but is ultimately not required to take into account the final losses. This may give rise to imbalances between the Member States in respect of the exercise of their powers of taxation and thereby impair the functioning of the internal market.
83 Furthermore, in the context of the freedom of establishment, if the Marks & Spencer exception is maintained and the associated departure from the principle of territoriality is permitted, that also carries the risk of worldwide importation of losses. The Court’s case-law seems to suggest at least that, on the basis of the free movement of capital, Member States should take into account losses from third countries in order to reduce taxation. (37)
84 In view of the legal uncertainty created by the exception recognised in the judgment in Marks & Spencer, cross-border use of losses no longer constitutes the least onerous means from the perspective of taxable persons. The body of the Court’s case-law concerning the interpretation and application of that judgment, which now extends over more than 20 years, shows that the solution in the individual case which appeared proportionate in relation to the situation underlying that judgment ultimately creates more legal uncertainty than legal clarity. It is still unclear today what final losses precisely are and what situations are intended to be covered by the judgment in Marks & Spencer. (38) In particular, there are doubts that taking into account losses accumulated over several years, as sought by the applicants in the main proceedings, can be justified on the basis of the Marks & Spencer exception. (39)
85 The impracticality of the Marks & Spencer exception is confirmed by the present request for a preliminary ruling and the widely divergent application practice in the Member States. It is difficult for the Member States and taxable persons to foresee whether and what losses ultimately must be taken into account exceptionally on a cross-border basis.
86 It is true that, in its judgment in Bevola, the Court ruled that final losses of a non-resident permanent establishment must be taken into account on a cross-border basis, irrespective of whether the company that maintains it has opted for a system of joint international taxation. (40) It would be disproportionate not to take into account those losses. However, the particular legal and factual background of that case differs significantly from the background in the main proceedings at issue in this case.
87 First, the judgment in Bevola concerned the use of losses of permanent establishments and not, as in this case, of subsidiaries. As has already been discussed, permanent establishments are dependent entities and it is therefore logical to tax their profits and losses at the level of the company that maintains them, unless that is expressly precluded, for example by a double taxation convention (41) or the domestic tax legislation of the State in which that company is resident. Subsidiaries, on the other hand, are independent legal persons which are not automatically taxed together with their parent company.
88 Second, the Danish law applicable in the judgment in Bevola provided for the possibility, in principle, of joint international taxation of companies with their non-resident permanent establishments. That is not possible for parent companies and their non-resident subsidiaries under French tax law, however. Accordingly, in Bevola cross-border use of losses of non-resident permanent establishments did not jeopardise the preservation of the allocation of the power to impose taxes between the Member States and the maintenance of the coherence of the Danish tax system in the same way as it would with regard to the French tax system in the main proceedings in this case.
89 As long as the regulation of direct taxation is a matter for the Member States and is not harmonised at EU level, EU citizens must therefore accept, in principle, (42) that the exercise of the freedom of establishment may become less attractive as a result of the powers of taxation laid down by Member States in that area. (43)
90 Consequently, should the Court accept the objective comparability of the situations at issue, contrary to what I propose, a scheme such as that provided for in Article 223 A et seq. of the French CGI, under which, in the context of a tax integration scheme, it is impossible to offset the final losses of a non-resident subsidiary of a company in the group against the overall profit of that group, would nevertheless be compatible with the freedom of establishment.
VI. Conclusion
91 In the light of those considerations, I propose that the Court of Justice answer the questions referred by the Conseil d’État (Council of State, France) as follows:
(1) The situation of a resident parent company wishing to have losses of a resident subsidiary taken into account in its taxation is not objectively comparable with the situation of a resident parent company seeking to have losses of a non-resident subsidiary taken into account if, pursuant to the rules on the territoriality of tax or pursuant to a double taxation convention, the State in which the parent companies are resident does not tax the profits of the non-resident subsidiary situated in another Member State.
(2) Should the Court accept objective comparability, a scheme such as that provided for in Article 223 A et seq. of the French Code général des impôts (General Tax Code), under which, in the context of a tax integration scheme, it is impossible to offset the final losses of a non-resident subsidiary of a company in the group against the overall profit of that group, is compatible with the freedom of establishment.
1 Original language: German.
2 Judgment of 13 December 2005 (C‑446/03, EU:C:2005:763).
3 See judgments of 27 November 2008, Papillon (C‑418/07, EU:C:2008:659); of 25 February 2010, X Holding (C‑337/08, EU:C:2010:89); and of 2 September 2015, Groupe Steria (C‑386/14, EU:C:2015:524).
4 See Article 4, read in conjunction with Article 18, of the France-Belgium Double Taxation Convention of 10 March 1964.
5 See Article 7(1) of the France-Latvia Double Taxation Convention of 14 April 1997.
6 See Article 7(1) of the France-Czechoslovakia Double Taxation Convention of 1 June 1973, which is applicable to relations between France and Slovakia.
7 Judgments of 15 May 1997, Futura Participations and Singer (C‑250/95, EU:C:1997:239, paragraph 22), and of 13 December 2005, Marks & Spencer (C‑446/03, EU:C:2005:763, paragraph 39).
8 See judgment of 13 December 2005, Marks & Spencer (C‑446/03, EU:C:2005:763, paragraph 55).
9 See judgments of 7 November 2013, K (C‑322/11, EU:C:2013:716, paragraphs 76 to 79); of 3 February 2015, Commission v United Kingdom (C‑172/13, EU:C:2015:50, paragraph 33); and of 19 June 2019, Memira Holding (C‑607/17, EU:C:2019:510, paragraph 28), and of 19 June 2019, Holmen (C‑608/17, EU:C:2019:511, paragraph 39).
10 See judgments of 14 February 1995, Schumacker (C‑279/93, EU:C:1995:31, paragraph 21); of 18 July 2007, Oy AA (C‑231/05, EU:C:2007:439, paragraph 18); and of 12 March 2026, Chefquet (C‑119/24, EU:C:2026:189, paragraph 29).
11 See judgment of 22 September 2022, W (Deductibility of final losses of a non-resident permanent establishment) (C‑538/20, EU:C:2022:717, paragraph 14).
12 See judgments of 27 September 1988, Daily Mail and General Trust (81/87, EU:C:1988:456, paragraph 16); of 29 November 2011, National Grid Indus (C‑371/10, EU:C:2011:785, paragraph 35); and of 22 September 2022, W (Deductibility of final losses of a non-resident permanent establishment) (C‑538/20, EU:C:2022:717, paragraph 15).
13 Judgments of 22 December 2008, Truck Center (C‑282/07, EU:C:2008:762, paragraph 33); of 23 November 2017, A (C‑292/16, EU:C:2017:888, paragraph 25); and of 21 December 2023, Cofidis (C‑340/22, EU:C:2023:1019, paragraph 40).
14 See judgments of 27 November 2008, Papillon (C‑418/07, EU:C:2008:659, paragraph 21), and of 2 September 2015, Groupe Steria (C‑386/14, EU:C:2015:524, paragraphs 19 and 20) with regard to French group taxation rules. See, with regard to Netherlands group taxation rules, judgment of 25 February 2010, X Holding (C‑337/08, EU:C:2010:89, paragraphs 18 and 19).
15 Judgments of 7 September 2004, Manninen (C‑319/02, EU:C:2004:484, paragraph 29); of 25 February 2010, X Holding (C‑337/08, EU:C:2010:89, paragraph 20); and of 22 September 2022, W (Deductibility of final losses of a non-resident permanent establishment) (C‑538/20, EU:C:2022:717, paragraph 18).
16 See judgments of 27 November 2008, Papillon (C‑418/07, EU:C:2008:659, paragraph 27); of 12 June 2014, SCA Group Holding and Others (C‑39/13 to C‑41/13, EU:C:2014:1758, paragraph 28); and of 30 April 2025, Finanzamt für Großbetriebe (C‑602/23, EU:C:2025:290, paragraph 52).
17 See, with regard to symmetry of taxation of profits and losses, my Opinion in Gena (C‑430/25, EU:C:2026:867, point 91), as well as judgments of 15 May 2008, Lidl Belgium (C‑414/06, EU:C:2008:278, paragraph 33); of 7 November 2013, K (C‑322/11, EU:C:2013:716, paragraph 51); and of 21 December 2023, Cofidis (C‑340/22, EU:C:2023:1019, paragraph 60).
18 See, in a context where losses of non-resident permanent establishments are taken into account, judgments of 17 July 2014, Nordea Bank Danmark (C‑48/13, EU:C:2014:2087, paragraph 24 and the case-law cited), and of 17 December 2015, Timac Agro Deutschland (C‑388/14, EU:C:2015:829, paragraphs 64 and 65). See, with regard to taxation of dividends, judgment of 17 September 2015, Miljoen and Others (C‑10/14, C‑14/14 and C‑17/14, EU:C:2015:608, paragraph 67 and the case-law cited). See, with regard to deduction of losses incurred in one Member State after the transfer of the place of management to another Member State, judgment of 27 February 2020, AURES Holdings (C‑405/18, EU:C:2020:127, paragraphs 39 to 41 and the case-law cited). See, with regard to the tax treatment of transactions corresponding to the recovery, by a company, of write-downs recorded prior to the transfer of its registered office, judgment of 10 November 2022, VP CAPITAL (C‑414/21, EU:C:2022:871, paragraphs 24 to 26), and, with regard to the imposition of a ‘fairness tax’, judgment of 12 December 2024, Volvo Group Belgium (C‑436/23, EU:C:2024:1023, paragraph 34).
19 Judgment of 22 September 2022, W (Deductibility of final losses of a non-resident permanent establishment) (C‑538/20, EU:C:2022:717, paragraph 27).
20 See Opinion of Advocate General Mancini in Commission v France (270/83, EU:C:1985:413, point 10), and judgments of 13 December 2005, Marks & Spencer (C‑446/03, EU:C:2005:763, paragraph 39), and of 25 February 2010, X Holding (C‑337/08, EU:C:2010:89, paragraph 38).
21 See also, to that effect, judgment of 25 February 2010, X Holding (C‑337/08, EU:C:2010:89, paragraph 43).
22 See judgment of 25 February 2010, X Holding (C‑337/08, EU:C:2010:89, paragraph 38).
23 See judgment of 13 December 2005, Marks & Spencer (C‑446/03, EU:C:2005:763, paragraph 39).
24 Judgment of 12 June 2018, Bevola and Jens W. Trock (C‑650/16, EU:C:2018:424, paragraphs 36, 39 and 40).
25 Judgment of 22 September 2022, W (Deductibility of final losses of a non-resident permanent establishment) (C‑538/20, EU:C:2022:717, paragraph 27).
26 See judgment of 22 September 2022, W (Deductibility of final losses of a non-resident permanent establishment) (C‑538/20, EU:C:2022:717, paragraphs 22 to 25).
27 See judgment of 6 December 2007, Columbus Container Services (C‑298/05, EU:C:2007:754, paragraphs 46 and 47).
28 In the Federal Republic of Germany, for example; see Article 59(2) of the Grundgesetz (Basic Law).
29 See, in that regard, Article 7 of the OECD Model Tax Convention 2017, condensed version. See also the commentary on that article on p. 175: ‘The first principle underlying paragraph 1, i.e. that the profits of an enterprise of one Contracting State shall not be taxed in the other State unless the enterprise carries on business in that other State through a permanent establishment situated therein, has a long history and reflects the international consensus that, as a general rule, until an enterprise of one State has a permanent establishment in another State, it should not properly be regarded as participating in the economic life of that other State to such an extent that the other State should have taxing rights on its profits’ (emphasis added).
30 See judgment of 13 December 2005, Marks & Spencer (C‑446/03, EU:C:2005:763, paragraph 55).
31 See judgment of 25 February 2010, X Holding (C‑337/08, EU:C:2010:89, paragraphs 30 to 33).
32 See judgments of 22 September 2022, W (Deductibility of final losses of a non-resident permanent establishment) (C‑538/20, EU:C:2022:717, paragraph 18), and of 4 October 2024, Staatssecretaris van Financiën (Interest in respect of an intra-group loan) (C‑585/22, EU:C:2024:822, paragraphs 33 and 53).
33 See judgments of 25 February 2010, X Holding (C‑337/08, EU:C:2010:89, paragraph 28); of 7 November 2013, K (C‑322/11, EU:C:2013:716, paragraph 65); and of 12 June 2018, Bevola and Jens W. Trock (C‑650/16, EU:C:2018:424, paragraphs 42 and 45).
34 See judgments of 7 November 2013, K (C‑322/11, EU:C:2013:716, paragraph 66); of 30 June 2016, Feilen (C‑123/15, EU:C:2016:496, paragraph 30); and of 12 June 2018, Bevola and Jens W. Trock (C‑650/16, EU:C:2018:424, paragraph 45).
35 See also, to that effect, judgment of 7 November 2013, K (C‑322/11, EU:C:2013:716, paragraph 69).
36 See, in that regard, Lang, M., ‘Has the Case Law of the ECJ on Final Losses Reached the End of the Line’, in European Taxation, 2014 (Volume 54), No 12, p. 530 (539), who refers to the possibility of initially taking into account losses of non-resident subsidiaries and deducting them again when profits are generated.
37 See judgment of 19 December 2024, Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) (C‑601/23, EU:C:2024:1048, in particular paragraphs 74 to 76).
38 See also, in that regard, Hey, J., ‘Taxation of business in the EU: Special problems of crossborder losses and exit taxation’, in Research Handbook on European Union Taxation Law, Cheltenham, United Kingdom, 2020, pp. 194 to 223 (211), who describes cross-border use of losses as a ‘fata morgana’.
39 See judgment of 3 February 2015, Commission v United Kingdom (C‑172/13, EU:C:2015:50, paragraph 37).
40 See judgment of 12 June 2018, Bevola and Jens W. Trock (C‑650/16, EU:C:2018:424).
41 Judgment of 22 September 2022, W (Deductibility of final losses of a non-resident permanent establishment) (C‑538/20, EU:C:2022:717, paragraph 27).
42 In exceptional cases, however, the limits of what is acceptable may be exceeded despite the absence of harmonisation in the regulation of direct taxation. See my Opinion in Gena (C‑430/25, EU:C:2026:867) with regard to Polish exit taxation.
43 See also, to that effect, Opinion of Advocate General Maduro in Marks & Spencer (C‑446/03, EU:C:2005:201, point 60), in which he states that ‘in the absence of Community harmonisation, the Court is not competent to interfere in the conception or organisation of the tax systems of the Member States’. See also, in that regard, Hey, J., ‘Taxation of business in the EU: Special problems of crossborder losses and exit taxation’, in Research Handbook on European Union Taxation Law, Cheltenham, United Kingdom, 2020, pp. 194 to 223 (211): ‘Without harmonisation, a coherent solution in line with the mechanisms of international tax law is not achievable, however, further harmonisation depends on the political will of the Member States, and not the Court of Justice.’