Details
ECLI
Source
Decision form
Issue date
Last update
File mark
Court
Jurisdiction
Judge
Žiadne známe citácie.
62024TO0001_en.html
HTML · 29.03 KB
No categories available
62024TO0001
Provisional text
ORDER OF THE GENERAL COURT (Seventh Chamber)
3 August 2026 (*)
In Joined Cases T‑1/24 DEP and T‑47/24 DEP,
Kartroi LLC, established in Orlando, Florida (United States), represented by M. Baccarelli, lawyer,
applicant,
v
European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO),
defendant,
the other party to the proceedings before the Board of Appeal of EUIPO, intervener before the General Court, being
Luxvide Finanziaria per Iniziative Audiovisive e Telematiche SpA, established in Rome (Italy), represented by L. Goglia and B. Villa, lawyers,
THE GENERAL COURT (Seventh Chamber),
composed of K. Kecsmár, President, P. Nihoul and U. Öberg (Rapporteur), Judges,
Registrar: V. Di Bucci,
having regard to the judgments of 3 September 2025, Kartroi v EUIPO – Luxvide Finanziaria per Iniziative Audiovisive e Telematiche (SANDOKAN) (T‑1/24, not published, EU:T:2025:818), and of 3 September 2025, Kartroi v EUIPO – Luxvide Finanziaria per Iniziative Audiovisive e Telematiche (SANDOKAN) (T‑47/24, not published, EU:T:2025:819),
makes the following
Order
1 By its applications, based on Article 170 of the Rules of Procedure of the General Court, the intervener, Luxvide Finanziaria per Iniziative Audiovisive e Telematiche SpA, requests the Court to fix at EUR 32 029.72 the amount of recoverable costs to be paid by the applicant, Kartroi LLC, in respect of the costs which the intervener incurred in the proceedings in Cases T‑1/24 and T‑47/24 and in the present proceedings for taxation of costs.
Background to the dispute
2 By applications lodged at the Registry of the General Court on 2 January 2024 and 30 January 2024, registered under case numbers T‑1/24 and T‑47/24 respectively, the applicant brought two actions seeking annulment of, first, a decision of the Second Board of Appeal of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) of 21 September 2023 (Case R 20/2023-2) and, second, a decision of the Second Board of Appeal of EUIPO of 31 October 2023 (Case R 312/2023-2).
3 The intervener intervened in the proceedings in support of the form of order sought by EUIPO and contended that the actions should be dismissed and the applicant be ordered to pay the costs.
4 By two judgments of 3 September 2025, Kartroi v EUIPO – Luxvide Finanziaria per Iniziative Audiovisive e Telematiche (SANDOKAN) (T‑1/24, not published, EU:T:2025:818), and of 3 September 2025, Kartroi v EUIPO – Luxvide Finanziaria per Iniziative Audiovisive e Telematiche (SANDOKAN) (T‑47/24, not published, EU:T:2025:819), the Court dismissed the actions and ordered the applicant to pay the costs incurred by the intervener.
5 By letter of 4 September 2025, the intervener requested that the applicant reimburse it the sum of EUR 23 274.59 in respect of recoverable costs relating to the proceedings that gave rise to the judgments in the main proceedings.
6 No agreement was reached between the parties on the amount of recoverable costs.
Forms of order sought
7 The intervener claims that the Court should:
– fix the amount of recoverable costs, to be reimbursed by the applicant, at EUR 11 637.30 in respect of the main proceedings in each case;
– fix the recoverable costs, to be borne by the applicant, at EUR 4 377.56 in respect of the present proceedings in each case.
8 The applicant contends, in essence, that the Court should reduce the amounts claimed by the intervener as recoverable costs.
Law
9 Having heard the views of the parties, the Court has decided to join the present cases for the purposes of the order, in accordance with Article 68 of the Rules of Procedure.
10 Under Article 170(3) of the Rules of Procedure, if there is a dispute concerning the costs to be recovered, the Court is, on application by the party concerned, to give its decision by way of an order from which no appeal is to lie, after giving the party concerned by the application an opportunity to submit his or her observations.
11 In accordance with Article 140(b) of the Rules of Procedure, ‘expenses necessarily incurred by the parties for the purpose of the proceedings, in particular the travel and subsistence expenses and the remuneration of agents, advisers or lawyers’ are to be regarded as recoverable costs. It follows from that provision that recoverable costs are limited to those incurred for the purpose of the proceedings before the General Court and which were necessary for that purpose (see order of 6 March 2003, Nan Ya Plastics and Far Eastern Textiles v Council, T‑226/00 DEP and T‑227/00 DEP, EU:T:2003:61, paragraph 33 and the case-law cited).
12 Article 170(3) of the Rules of Procedure, read in the light of Article 134(1) of those rules, is based on the principle that the unsuccessful party is to be ordered to pay the costs of the successful party. The successful party must be put in the position in which they would have been had the other party not brought proceedings or defended its case. By contrast, the EU judicature must not order the unsuccessful party to pay the costs incurred by the successful party in connection with the proceedings, in so far as those costs were not strictly necessary.
13 It is settled case-law that, in the absence of provisions of EU law laying down fee scales or the length of time necessary for the work to be done, the Court must freely assess the details of the case, taking account of the subject matter and nature of the dispute, its importance from the point of view of EU law and also the difficulties presented by the case, the amount of work which the contentious proceedings generated for the agents or counsel involved, and the economic interests which the dispute presented for the parties (see order of 26 January 2017, Nürburgring v EUIPO – Biedermann (Nordschleife), T‑181/14 DEP, EU:T:2017:41, paragraph 11 and the case-law cited).
14 As regards the hourly rate, in the absence of a scale in that regard, it is only where the average hourly rate invoiced appears manifestly excessive that the Court may depart from it and set ex aequo et bono the amount of recoverable fees for lawyers (see, to that effect, order of 21 December 2023, FFI Female Financial Invest v EUIPO – MLP Finanzberatung (Financery), T‑7/22 DEP, not published, EU:T:2023:872, paragraph 23 and the case-law cited). Depending on the characteristics of the case, and in particular for those where the degree of complexity is limited, that also applies to the amount of fees for lawyers charged on a flat-rate basis.
15 The Court, in fixing recoverable costs, takes account of all the circumstances of the case up to the making of the order on taxation of costs, including expenses necessarily incurred in relation to the taxation of costs proceedings (order of 21 December 2023, Financery, T‑7/22 DEP, not published, EU:T:2023:872, paragraph 13).
16 The amount of the costs recoverable in the present cases must be determined in accordance with those considerations.
17 It is apparent from the case file that the intervener applied for the reimbursement of a total amount of EUR 32 029.72, including value added tax (VAT). The intervener produced five invoices in support of its application:
– an invoice of 3 September 2024 relating to Case T‑1/24, concerning ‘LUX VIDE – [EU COURT] – [REVOCATION]’ in the amount of EUR 8 372 excluding VAT, corresponding to fees in the amount of EUR 7 000, ‘overheads’ of 15% in the amount of EUR 1 050 and the contribution to Cassa Previdenza Avvocati (‘the CPA’) of 4% in the amount of EUR 322, plus EUR 1 841.84 VAT;
– an invoice of 3 September 2024 relating to Case T‑47/24, concerning ‘LUX VIDE – [EU COURT] – [INVALIDITY]’ in the amount of EUR 8 372 excluding VAT, corresponding to fees in the amount of EUR 7 000, ‘overheads’ of 15% in the amount of EUR 1 050 and the contribution to the CPA of 4% in the amount of EUR 322, plus EUR 1 841.84 VAT;
– an invoice of 20 December 2024 relating to the hearings in Cases T‑1/24 and T‑47/24, concerning ‘LUX VIDE – [EU COURT] – [REVOCATION]’ in the amount of EUR 2 333.53 excluding VAT, corresponding to fees in the amount of EUR 1 000, ‘overheads’ of 15% in the amount of EUR 150, ‘taxable costs’ in the amount of EUR 1 093.78 and the contribution to the CPA of 4% in the amount of EUR 89.75, plus EUR 513.38 VAT;
– an invoice of 10 October 2025, concerning ‘LUX VIDE – [EU COURT] – [REVOCATION]’ drawn up for the ‘preparation and lodging of an action with a view to the settlement of costs relating to Case T‑1/24 before the General Court of the European Union’ in the amount of EUR 3 588 excluding VAT, corresponding to fees in the amount of EUR 3 000, ‘overheads’ of 15% in the amount of EUR 450 and the contribution to the CPA of 4% in the amount of EUR 138, plus EUR 789.36 VAT;
– an invoice of 10 October 2025, concerning ‘LUX VIDE – [EU COURT] – [INVALIDITY]’ drawn up for the ‘preparation and lodging of an action with a view to the settlement of costs relating to Case T‑47/24 before the General Court of the European Union’ in the amount of EUR 3 588 excluding VAT, corresponding to fees in the amount of EUR 3 000, ‘general costs’ of 15% in the amount of EUR 450 and the contribution to the CPA of 4% in the amount of EUR 138, plus EUR 789.36 VAT.
18 In respect of all of those invoices, the intervener produced, by way of evidence and in order to demonstrate that they were expenses necessarily incurred for the purpose of the proceedings, email exchanges with its lawyer containing quotes, from which it is apparent that the lawyers’ fees were fixed at a flat rate and not on the basis of an hourly rate.
Lawyers’ fees
The lawyers’ fees relating to the main proceedings
19 It is apparent from the case file that the total amount of the lawyers’ fees which the intervener seeks to have reimbursed, in respect of the main proceedings, is EUR 15 000 excluding VAT, namely EUR 7 000 for each written part and EUR 500 for each oral part.
20 In the first place, as regards the subject matter and nature of the dispute, its importance from the point of view of EU law and the difficulties presented by the case, it must be noted that the cases in the main proceedings concerned actions brought against decisions of the Board of Appeal of EUIPO relating, first, to revocation proceedings for lack of genuine use and, second, invalidity proceedings on the ground of absolute nullity.
21 Consequently, the cases in the main proceedings were part of recurrent litigation before the Court and did not concern issues that were particularly complex, either in law or in fact, or were of particular importance with respect to EU law, which, moreover, is not disputed by the intervener. Those cases cannot therefore be regarded as presenting particular difficulties. In addition, they did not raise a new question of law and could be dealt with on the basis of settled case-law.
22 In the second place, as regards the economic interests at stake, the intervener claims that the proceedings were of crucial importance for the free exercise of its economic activity, in particular to clear the way within the European Union for possible further actions and claims by the applicant, which would have had repercussions on the development and distribution of its ‘Sandokan’ series, although that series had already required significant investment. In that regard, the intervener refers to several press articles which, in its view, demonstrate the scale of the investment that it made and the work that it carried out to produce that series.
23 It must be noted that those press articles in no way demonstrate the investments made or the work carried out by the intervener to produce the ‘Sandokan’ series, but merely repeat the statements made by associates of the intervener in that regard. Those statements are not supported by any evidence.
24 Thus, although, in the light of the importance of trade marks in trade, the case was clearly of economic interest to the intervener, in the absence of evidence adduced by the intervener, that financial interest cannot be regarded as unusually significant.
25 In the third place, as regards the amount of the work that the main proceedings generated for the intervener, the primary consideration of the Courts of the European Union is the total number of hours of work which may appear to be objectively necessary for the purpose of the proceedings before the Court. In that regard, the ability of the Courts of the European Union to assess the value of work carried out is dependent on the accuracy of the information provided (see, to that effect, order of 17 March 2016, Norma Lebensmittelfilialbetrieb v OHIM – Yorma’s (Yorma Eberl), T‑229/14 DEP, not published, EU:T:2016:177, paragraph 19 and the case-law cited).
26 In the present cases, as stated in paragraph 18 above, the lawyers’ fees were fixed at a flat rate. On that point, the intervener submits that, if the amount invoiced as lawyers’ fees was divided by an hourly rate of EUR 350 – a rate which the Court has recognised as appropriate on several occasions – that amount would correspond to approximately 21 hours of work per case. Thus, according to the intervener, the total amount of the fees must necessarily be regarded as fair and justified.
27 Since the intervener did not provide details regarding the number of hours its representative dedicated to preparing the case, drafting the response or participating in the hearing, it is for the Courts of the European Union to consider the work which may appear to be objectively necessary and reasonable for that type of litigation before the Court (see, to that effect, order of 7 May 2020, Gibson Brands v EUIPO – Wilfer (Shape of a guitar body), T‑340/18 DEP, not published, EU:T:2020:206, paragraph 36).
28 In that regard, it should be noted, first, that the cases in the main proceedings each comprised a written part, including an exchange of written pleadings, and an oral part, during which a hearing took place on 5 December 2024.
29 The applicant’s applications in Cases T‑1/24 and T‑47/24 were 20 pages and 22 annexes, and 21 pages and 15 annexes respectively. EUIPO’s responses were 13 pages and 12 annexes, and 16 pages respectively. The intervener lodged two responses, which were 13 pages and 12 annexes, and 14 pages and 18 annexes respectively.
30 In addition, the proceedings included an oral part and the intervener was represented by a lawyer at the oral hearings in the two cases. The combined duration of the two oral hearings, as is apparent from the record, was 2 hours and 18 minutes.
31 Second, contrary to what the applicant claims, the cases which gave rise to the judgments in the main proceedings were not similar in law and in fact. Case T‑1/24 concerned revocation proceedings for lack of genuine use and Case T‑47/24 concerned invalidity proceedings on the ground of bad faith when the trade mark application was filed.
32 Third, the intervener explained that the parts of the proceedings before EUIPO had been managed by a company specialising in intellectual property consultancy services, made up of professionals registered in the Italian and European registers of industrial property consultants, which was, however, unable to represent the intervener before the Court. That company did not have among its staff any professionals authorised to practise as lawyers before the Italian courts. Thus, since the intervener’s lawyers in the main proceedings did not represent the intervener before EUIPO, they did not already have knowledge of the dispute. It is therefore necessary to take account of the additional working time spent reviewing the case file prior to preparing the responses.
33 In the light of all those factors, the fixed amounts of lawyers’ fees of EUR 7 000 for each written part and EUR 500 for each oral part must be regarded as objectively necessary costs. It follows that the lawyers’ fees necessary for the main proceedings must be fixed at EUR 15 000.
The lawyers’ fees relating to the present taxation of costs proceedings
34 In the present proceedings on taxation of costs, the intervener seeks reimbursement of lawyers’ fees of EUR 6 000 excluding VAT, that is to say, EUR 3 000 excluding VAT for each case.
35 As is the case for the lawyers’ fees relating to the main proceedings, the lawyers’ fees relating to the proceedings on taxation of costs were fixed at a flat rate and not on the basis of an hourly rate.
36 In that regard, it must be borne in mind that an application for taxation of costs is of a fairly standardised nature and is characterised, generally, by the absence of any difficulty for the lawyer who has already dealt with the substance of the case, particularly when the latter does not involve any specific difficulty, as was the case here in the main proceedings (see order of 21 December 2023, Financery, T‑7/22 DEP, not published, EU:T:2023:872, paragraph 33 and the case-law cited).
37 Furthermore, the applications for taxation of costs made by the intervener in the two joined cases are strictly identical.
38 In those circumstances, it must be held that the total fixed amount of EUR 6 000 for lawyers’ fees is excessive. The amount of recoverable lawyers’ fees relating to the present taxation of costs proceedings must be fixed, on an ex aequo et bono basis, at EUR 2 400 for both cases.
Disbursements and VAT
39 The intervener seeks reimbursement of an amount corresponding to 15% of the total lawyers’ fees in respect of ‘overheads’, EUR 1 093.78 in respect of ‘taxable costs’, 4% of those fees and those costs in respect of the contribution to the CPA, and the VAT invoiced to it.
40 As regards ‘overheads’ in the amount of EUR 2 250 for the main proceedings and EUR 900 for the present proceedings, the intervener submits that the assessment of those costs is based on Italian domestic legislation.
41 In that regard, it must be noted that the secretarial, typing, postage and telephone expenses should be treated as recoverable costs since they appear to be properly justified and to have been assessed on a reasonable basis (orders of 2 June 2009, Sison v Council, T‑47/03 DEP, EU:T:2009:166, paragraph 51, and of 25 November 2009, Hynix Semiconductor v Council, T‑383/03 DEP, not published, EU:T:2009:466, paragraph 54).
42 In the present cases, the amount of ‘overheads’ claimed by the intervener results from the application of Article 2(2) of decreto ministeriale n. 55, Regolamento recante la determinazione dei parametri per la liquidazione dei compensi per la professione forense, ai sensi dell’articolo 13 comma 6 della Legge 31 dicembre 2012 n. 247 (Ministerial Decree No 55 setting the criteria for calculating lawyers’ fees, in accordance with Article 13(6) of Law No 247 of 31 December 2012) of 10 March 2014.
43 It follows that an amount of EUR 2 610, corresponding to 15% of the amount of the lawyers’ fees assessed by the Court in paragraphs 33 and 38 above, can be regarded as recoverable in the present cases in respect of ‘overheads’.
44 As regards the ‘taxable costs’ in the amount of EUR 1 093.78, the intervener submits that these are the costs incurred for the return flights between Milan and Luxembourg, accommodation in Luxembourg, taxi transport to and from the airports or to the Court and meals consumed during the trip. Those costs are supported by documentary evidence.
45 As is apparent from those supporting documents, those costs are directly linked to the intervener’s participation in the oral hearings. The sum of EUR 1 093.78 must therefore be held to be fully recoverable costs.
46 As regards the amounts invoiced in respect of the CPA, it must be noted that those amounts are payable as contributions to the social security fund for lawyers and are therefore recoverable costs (see, to that effect, orders of 20 May 2022, Moi v Parliament, T‑17/19 DEP, not published, EU:T:2022:352, paragraph 87, and of 23 January 2024, Tubes Radiatori v EUIPO – Antrax It (Radiator for heating), T‑380/20 DEP, not published, EU:T:2024:39, paragraph 59).
47 It follows that that an amount of EUR 844.15, corresponding to 4% of the amount of the lawyers’ fees, overheads and taxable costs assessed by the Court in paragraphs 33, 38, 43 and 44 above, can be regarded as recoverable in the present cases in respect of the contribution to the CPA.
48 As regards the amounts invoiced in respect of VAT, it must be observed that when a natural or legal person is subject to VAT, he or she is entitled to recover from the tax authorities the VAT paid on the goods and services which he or she purchases. VAT thus does not represent expenditure for that person, with the result that the amounts paid in respect of that tax should not be taken into account for the purpose of calculating the recoverable costs. Consequently, the amount claimed in respect of VAT is regarded as recoverable costs only if the natural or legal person claiming that amount establishes that he, she or it is not subject to VAT (see, to that effect, order of 29 June 2015, Reber v OHIM – Klusmeier (Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart PREMIUM), T‑530/10 DEP, not published, EU:T:2015:482, paragraph 51 and the case-law cited).
49 Since the intervener has not provided any information in that regard, the amount of VAT is not included in the recoverable costs in the present cases.
The allegedly abusive or even vexatious conduct of the intervener
50 In support of its form of order seeking, in essence, that the Court reduce the amounts claimed by the intervener in respect of recoverable costs, the applicant asks the Court to take account of the allegedly abusive or even vexatious conduct of the intervener, in accordance with Article 135 of the Rules of Procedure.
51 That plea must be rejected as ineffective.
52 Although the abusive nature of one party’s conduct is relevant for the allocation of costs ordered by the Court in the final judgment or in the order which closes the proceedings, pursuant to Article 135 of the Rules of Procedure, that abuse is, however, of no relevance at the stage of the taxation of costs, effected by the Court pursuant to Article 140(b) of those rules, since taxation is an objective procedure, the aim of which is to determine the necessary costs incurred for the purpose of the proceedings.
53 In the light of all of the foregoing, the amount of costs recoverable by the intervener is fixed at EUR 21 947.93, including EUR 17 400 in respect of lawyers’ fees, plus 15% in respect of ‘overheads’, amounting to EUR 2 610, and 4% in respect of the contribution to the CPA, amounting to EUR 844.15, as well as travel and subsistence expenses in the amount of EUR 1 093.78.
On those grounds,
THE GENERAL COURT (Seventh Chamber),
hereby orders:
The total amount of costs to be reimbursed by Kartroi LLC to Luxvide Finanziaria per Iniziative Audiovisive e Telematiche SpA is fixed at EUR 21 947.93.
Luxembourg, 3 August 2026.
V. Di Bucci
K. Kecsmár
Registrar
President
* Language of the case: Italian.